as much as i love timmmy and dunc, they should not be anywhere near the list of greats! from dixie, the holy trinity, young, hickson, labby and more, all of whom ive never witnessed, but won things at this club, i dont think any player in the last 20 years can come close (big nev the exception).
but as mike said, dixie should walk it, and rightly so!
edit; looking at some other clubs, luis garcia is on there for the rs! wigans has baines and matt jackson!