Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Memmaclub

With Everyone Fit Who Is The Best 11.

Recommended Posts

I am obviously basing mine on assuming both fellani and castillo can do a good job.

 

SO mine would be

 

Howard

 

Hibbo Jags Lescott Baines

Castillo

Arteta Fellani Cahill Piernar

Yak

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Howard

Nevill Yobo Jags J.Lo

Arteta Felaini Cahill Pienaar

Saha Yak

 

 

With people fully fit that is who I think would be our strongest 11.

 

I would agree with this team, maybe not Saha and put another midfielder (Osman) on as Cahill will wonder up and down anyway.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it was only his opinion....

 

mine would be

 

--------------howard---------------

 

neville----yobo-----jags------bains

 

--------------Castillio---------------

 

Arteta-----------------------Piernar

 

---------------Cahill-----------------

 

--------------Yakubu---------------

 

Then u have a strong bench to be able to swap around if things arent going to plan...slip castillio into a back 3 and have wing backs with an attacking front 4...the choice is endless!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
it was only his opinion....

 

mine would be

 

--------------howard---------------

 

neville----yobo-----jags------bains

 

--------------Castillio---------------

 

Arteta-----------------------Piernar

 

---------------Cahill-----------------

 

--------------Yakubu---------------

 

Then u have a strong bench to be able to swap around if things arent going to plan...slip castillio into a back 3 and have wing backs with an attacking front 4...the choice is endless!

 

in my opinion that would be our best starting 10 :P:P

throw in fellaini in the centre to make it our best starting 11

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
it was only his opinion....

 

mine would be

 

--------------howard---------------

 

neville----yobo-----jags------bains

 

--------------Castillio---------------

 

Arteta-----------------------Piernar

 

---------------Cahill-----------------

 

--------------Yakubu---------------

 

Then u have a strong bench to be able to swap around if things arent going to plan...slip castillio into a back 3 and have wing backs with an attacking front 4...the choice is endless!

 

 

Only 10 men!!!!! I didnt think we were that hard up for players!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Stick Screech just in front of Cas

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I would agree with this team, maybe not Saha and put another midfielder (Osman) on as Cahill will wonder up and down anyway.

I think that when fit Saha is a very very good striker and will give us alot of options up front. If fit we could actually play a decent 4-4-2 which in my opnion is what we should be aiming to play, as appose to a 451. It can be a little embarrasing when we end up playing 451 at home and the opposition is playing 442.

 

If Saha is fully fit I would want to see him starting. It may not happen very often tbh though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That's the one, Pienaar/Osman is a close shout though

Swap Castillio and Fellaini though. Fellaini's best position is just in front of back 4, and with the price we paid for him it would be foolish to play him out of position

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

................................Howard.................................

 

Neville............Yobo.................Jags...............Lescott

 

Osman............Castillo..........Fellaini...............Arteta

 

.................................Cahill...................................

 

.................................Yakuba................................

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

-----------------------------------HOWARD-------------------------------------

 

HIBBERT------------YOBO----------------------JAGIELKA----------LESCOTT

 

-----------------------------------CASTILLO------------------------------------

 

----------ARTETA-----------------FELLANI------------------CAHILL-----------

 

-------------------------YAK---------------------SAHA--------------------------

 

OR

 

-----------------------------------HOWARD-------------------------------------

 

HIBBERT------------YOBO----------------------JAGIELKA----------LESCOTT

 

-----------------------------------FELLANI--------------------------------------

 

----------ARTETA----------------CAHILL-----------------PIENAAR------------

 

-------------------------YAK-----------------SAHA------------------------------

 

Neville isnt good enough I dont give a shit what anyone else thinks....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
-----------------------------------HOWARD-------------------------------------

 

HIBBERT------------YOBO----------------------JAGIELKA----------LESCOTT

 

-----------------------------------FELLANI--------------------------------------

 

----------ARTETA----------------CAHILL-----------------PIENAAR------------

-------------------------YAK-----------------SAHA------------------------------

 

Neville isnt good enough I dont give a shit what anyone else thinks....

I'm glad someone else is thinking about playing two up front! I do think that you should at least be aiming for two strikers in the squad, and Saha is a very good striker, he just has huge fitness question marks around him. But seeing as this is the everyone is fit team then I can't see why more people don't want to see him in the squad.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
saha was one of the best strikers in the premiership a few years ago, why couldn't he still be? thats how I see it anyway.

 

VDM was one of the best players in Holland a few years ago, why couldnt he still be ??. :lol: :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i think saha can be quality for us, but for me 451 is a must, i see cahill as a bigger threat for us in his favoured advanced role than any of our strikers partnering the yak.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mornin chaps :whaa: i'd like to see Baines at LB myself as we know J.Lo has'nt been at his best of late i know its early doors at the mo but Baines gives us a little more pace down the line and i think he'd be more suited to playing off Pienaar, Saha when fit with Yak should be a topnotch pairing as i think they would complement each other quite well also with Timmy pushing up aswell it reeks goals to me. Either way 442 or 451 atleast we have good players to accommodate either formation now.

 

 

-----------------------------------HOWARD-------------------------------------

 

NEVILLE------------YOBO----------------------JAGIELKA----------BAINES

 

-----------------------------------FELLANI--------------------------------------

 

----------ARTETA----------------CAHILL-----------------PIENAAR------------

 

-------------------------YAK-----------------SAHA------------------------------

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
VDM was one of the best players in Holland a few years ago, why couldnt he still be ??. :lol: :lol:

Well if VDM was fit he would get on the bench for me. The few brief glimpses we have seen on him he has been good, his few appearances have been strong ones.... the problem being is that the last one was against West Ham when they still had Tevez playing for them.

 

Plus trying to draw comparisons between Saha and VDM is short sighted, Saha has been unlucky with injury but has still shone when he plays, VDM is often self-inflicting in his troubles.

 

Saha is still a clinical finsiher and is still strong in the air. For those reasons I would have him in my starting line up... if he was fit, he's far from past it yet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Well if VDM was fit he would get on the bench for me. The few brief glimpses we have seen on him he has been good, his few appearances have been strong ones.... the problem being is that the last one was against West Ham when they still had Tevez playing for them.

 

Really? Strong appearances??..you must have low standards, very looooooowwwwww.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Didnt mean to be derogatory as regards Saha, just pointing out that it is very poor reasoning to appraise a player on how good he was in the past, i could name 20 players who where good a few years ago but are crap now.

 

I'll hold off on my assessment of Louis Saha until i've actually seen him play half a dozen games.

But i could be waiting for a long time. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Really? Strong appearances??..you must have low standards, very looooooowwwwww.

I'm sorry but its true. When he has played, which has been on very very rare occaisons he has played well. His last league appearance against West Ham, he looked good and was probably our biggest threat on the pitch, in his first few games he set up a few goals and expectations where high, plus he has impressed in pre-season, year in year out only to fail on the fitness front.

 

It would be unfair to judge his on pitch ability on his off pitch antics. I'm not trying to say that he is a world beater on the pitch but he has played well when he has played (apart from the first derby which was a slight shambles).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Didnt mean to be derogatory as regards Saha, just pointing out that it is very poor reasoning to appraise a player on how good he was in the past, i could name 20 players who where good a few years ago but are crap now.

 

I'll hold off on my assessment of Louis Saha until i've actually seen him play half a dozen games.

But i could be waiting for a long time. :)

I wasn't trying to say that he was good in the past so will be good now, I think that he is still a good player. He is not a player who relys on his pace or anything like that so i think his ability has never really been in doubt, only his fitness. The problem i can see is that it could take a year to actually see a dozen games. We'll have to wait and see though I guess.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

-------------HOWARD------------

 

--HIBBO--YOBO--JAGS--LESCOTT

 

-------------FELAINI-------------

 

---ARTETA--CAHILL--PIENAAR---

 

-----------------SAHA-------------

 

------THE YAK---------------------

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×