Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Sprooly

Philippe Senderos Signed On Loan

Recommended Posts

I thought we'd at least sign Senderos. Apparently every bit of brilliance DM possesses is left on the pitch, with none left over for the summers. I hate summer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Taking everything as written...... If we have pulled out of the deal... well im sure it will be over Arsenals Valuation....... If Sunderland want to cough up more silly money let them.......

I dont mind seeing Moyes/Everton sticking to their guns over Transfer fees..... These players are just squad players anyway...Id have a different view on it if they were "1st Team" buys.

I think we will/should be willing to move on fees if the player is a genuine 1st team buy that will improve the team....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I remember reading a quote from Martin O'Neill recently saying he wouldn't bankrupt Villa for the sake of paying over inflated prices. Moyes is sticking to his guns too, which is good to see.

 

How naive! Moyes gets too much praise for this one, he can't pay because he hasn't the money to get close to a valuation. As usual names are discussed and thrown at the media to suppress anger and annoyance amongst the fans, the reality is unless Kenwright can convince Moyes to sell Lescott and stay in his job, we have NO cash to sign anybody.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How naive! Moyes gets too much praise for this one, he can't pay because he hasn't the money to get close to a valuation. As usual names are discussed and thrown at the media to suppress anger and annoyance amongst the fans, the reality is unless Kenwright can convince Moyes to sell Lescott and stay in his job, we have NO cash to sign anybody.

 

How do you know...... You keep telling us we have no money but your basing this on what fact.......

 

As I see it we were willing to spend.... 4-6m on a rightback that was going to sit on the bench........ I can think of other things to spend my money on....

 

Tha Facts ARE.... HE HAS A BUDGET.... WHATEVER IT MAY BE.......

 

You carnt just start paying over the odds....do you not get it.....

 

ie if you have 2 players lined up...... both valued at 5m and we have 10m budet........you carnt go and offer 6 just because someone else comes along offering silly money........

 

we fail because other teams have BIGGER budgets... v simple...... Sunderland Villa City Portsmouth all have new mega rich owners

 

Stop saying we have "NO MONEY" we do..... we just carnt compete with the mega rich out there

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How do you know...... You keep telling us we have no money but your basing this on what fact.......

 

As I see it we were willing to spend.... 4-6m on a rightback that was going to sit on the bench........ I can think of other things to spend my money on....

 

Tha Facts ARE.... HE HAS A BUDGET.... WHATEVER IT MAY BE.......

 

You carnt just start paying over the odds....do you not get it.....

 

ie if you have 2 players lined up...... both valued at 5m and we have 10m budet........you carnt go and offer 6 just because someone else comes along offering silly money........

 

we fail because other teams have BIGGER budgets... v simple...... Sunderland Villa City Portsmouth all have new mega rich owners

 

Stop saying we have "NO MONEY" we do..... we just carnt compete with the mega rich out there

 

I agree DM.... people keep saying we have no budget, but I have not heard or seen anything to say that. We put in a bid for Naughton which was very good for a young, untried championship full back. Spurs came along and offered another Mill and better personal terms, cos they seem to have a bottomless pit and don't mind giving silly wages.

 

I think DM is right to stick to his valuation, whether that is buying or selling. Senderos will be cover for Jags, and will be benchbound for large parts of the season when Jags and Yobo are fit... do you want to spend £6m on him? I don't... would rather do the £8m on Taylor who could push both of the others regularly....

 

The lack of "ins" is very frustrating and I want to see some quality added... but if the quality doesn't come cos we have bought average players at overrated prices... that would piss me off more!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How do you know...... You keep telling us we have no money but your basing this on what fact.......

 

As I see it we were willing to spend.... 4-6m on a rightback that was going to sit on the bench........ I can think of other things to spend my money on....

 

Tha Facts ARE.... HE HAS A BUDGET.... WHATEVER IT MAY BE.......

 

You carnt just start paying over the odds....do you not get it.....

 

ie if you have 2 players lined up...... both valued at 5m and we have 10m budet........you carnt go and offer 6 just because someone else comes along offering silly money........

 

we fail because other teams have BIGGER budgets... v simple...... Sunderland Villa City Portsmouth all have new mega rich owners

 

Stop saying we have "NO MONEY" we do..... we just carnt compete with the mega rich out there

 

It's OK DM...you get used to just ignoring people like him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's OK DM...you get used to just ignoring people like him.

 

 

Im just pissed off with hearing the same old stories based on complete bulshit....... and unless the fella next to me has moved his season ticket im gonna have to listen to it all fucking season......So im anticipatimg a full blown argument tomorrow....Im ina bad mood already..... I can imaginge the fella booing non stop at Lescott... hes one of them Big Baldy meat head types that argues with EVERYONE near him......

 

ANYWAY......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First DM, calm down ffs! Second can you provide me evidence there IS money to spend, because Kenwright himself said many times he has no more cash to plough in. Everton like most teams either rely on loans or sky money to finance deals, and because on/off the pitch there isn't much money coming into the club like a United or Arsenal then most extra cash gets sucked into the debts.

 

Whether you like it or not (I know how you feel as I'm equally pissed about it) the club hasn't buttons to spend. You talked about finding the right player, even when we did like for Naughton part of the delay was us actually getting a loan together. It isn't easy when there isn't much to loan against except the sky money, that's the reality. We currently are still paying off part of the Felliani deal this year, so it isn't as easy as people DM or the village idiot thinks.

 

Anyway if you don't believe a word I said, please read:

 

http://www.sport.co.uk/news/Football/25122/No_place_to_hide_in_credit_league_as_Merseyside_clubs_enjoy_differing_fortunes_.aspx

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

senderos has probably signed for spurs by now. moyes, quite your flucking dithering and sign him...a few extra pennies don't need to be saved.

 

Ha, so I said the wrong club...shoulda seen Sunderland coming. I'd still like to see this one come off our way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ha, so I said the wrong club...shoulda seen Sunderland coming. I'd still like to see this one come off our way.

 

There remains hope, DM has states on the OS that he hopes there will be additions in the next 48hrs.. though he did emphasise the youth squad...

 

Anyway, 12hrs 40mins to go :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There remains hope, DM has states on the OS that he hopes there will be additions in the next 48hrs.. though he did emphasise the youth squad...

 

Anyway, 12hrs 40mins to go :)

 

 

He didnt even mention the youth squad!

 

"I hope maybe within the next 48 hours or so we will have a couple of new players added to the squad. If we do that then we will start to rebuild from the players we lost last season."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was thinking the same thing when ready that players were hoping to sign within 48 hours it would be just after the arse game but then it could also be shown before the game as cant play as not signed in time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Apparently your lot have only bid £2m for him and Sunderland big £6m. However, after watching Senderos play in the week Bruce withdrew his intrest.

 

As an Arsenal fan, I think he'd do well. He's got an issue with confidence but I think he'd suit your defensive style more than ours because you play deep and we don't. Senderos in one game can look world class and then a week later look average. He struggles against players with pace i.e Torres and he also troubles with Drogba but I do believe that's because of how high our defence play.

 

He'd be a good signing for your lot and I hope he does well if he signs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey Fellas hope ur not too dispondent, Arsenal fan here & i wont gloat about the result, I just thought id through my two penneth into your Senderos debate.

I truly think he could prove to be a really good signing for you & really cant believe some of the opinion/criticism towards the player on here.

Firstly because of the system wenger plays believe me most centre backs are gonna be exposed from time to time at arsenal. A combination of a high back line ( so if you aint got great pace your gonna struggle), marauding attack minded full backs & often little protection from midfield means its a far from easy task playing that position for us! This along with greater media attention on top 4 champs league teams means mistakes are gonna be highlighted far more often than with a lot of sides .

Ive always had a bit of a soft spot for Sendy who in my eyes is a bit of an old school defender, he isnt blessed with electric pace & unfortunately has a rather ungainly style that can often make him look rather clumsy & in my opinion attract more attention to an error than maybe a more stylish player would. But i defo think under the right system he could flourish & is a good no nonsense backs against the wall style defender.

He may be short on confidence at the moment but hey hes only 24 & i think he still has great potential. I also seem to remember a similar style of player, a certain Tony Adams getting donkey chants at the same age & he turned out ok! (please note im am not suggesting he will become an absolute legend like TA!)

Now If you are talking about valuations, i have seen 2 mill mentioned on here & thats a joke ( at those levels have a sniff round division 1). I think we sold Pascal Cygan who was a total joke for more than that! Actually he went on to do quite well in spain as it happens. Anyway If you value lescott at 30 mill :D then on those terms i would want 12 mill+ for sendy! But being serious, i think lescotts worth no more than 15mill unless city are bidding! Senderos was offered to Milan for 6m but he was unlucky with injuries there & perhaps wasnt the type of cultured stylish CB the Italians were after? Im sure Wenger who is very fair to players when it comes to letting them go would now release him for 5m, maybe 4millish + add ons or a percentage of a sell on fee at a push? Any less & it would be stupid. If you sign him God even if he totally bombed (which i dont think he would) say you wanted shut after a couple of years? Im sure a mid twentys player with top European experience & a proven international with over 30 caps for his country could still be offloaded onto the continent for 3-4 mill easy! Its a no brainer & if he did really well your looking at potentially 10 mill+ player with sell on value!

Get your money for Joleon 20 mill :) & snap up sendy & make a couple of smart additions with the remaining funds, that would be my advice.

Good luck for the rest of the season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Get your money for Joleon 20 mill :) & snap up sendy & make a couple of smart additions with the remaining funds, that would be my advice.

That's looking to be a no-brainer to most now, we just have to hope DM agrees :) . If not Senderos then Taylor maybe....or both would be better.

 

Thanks for the contribution blink.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He would be good on loan but hopefully Moyes doesn't spend money on him.

he would be a good loan deal who knows he may play well for us...im sure yobo is on his way next season so it would be a big opertunity for senderos.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heitinga and Jags should be our CB pairing so unless he wants to sit his arse on the bench he won't be coming here.

 

Plus, he makes even more mistakes than Yobo and then doesn't have the pace that Yobo has to try and make up for them. It was a no from me when this move first looked on and it's still a no from me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heitinga and Jags should be our CB pairing so unless he wants to sit his arse on the bench he won't be coming here.

 

Plus, he makes even more mistakes than Yobo and then doesn't have the pace that Yobo has to try and make up for them. It was a no from me when this move first looked on and it's still a no from me.

 

That for me would be our best pairing by far when we have a fit squad, I don't mind Senderos i think he's an ok player but he is prone to the odd clanger no worse then Yobo in my book.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

cant really see heitinga as a centre back in fact i dont know what position is going to be his best...im still not sure about him hes hard i will give him that and hes got a following on the st end but i want to see him in a settled position.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

cant really see heitinga as a centre back in fact i dont know what position is going to be his best...im still not sure about him hes hard i will give him that and hes got a following on the st end but i want to see him in a settled position.

 

Full name John Gijsbert Alan Heitinga

Date of birth 15 November 1983 (1983-11-15) (age 26)

Place of birth Alphen aan den Rijn, Netherlands

Height 1.80 m (5 ft 11 in)[1]

Playing position Defender

 

From what i have read about him previous to playing here most think that is his best position? I think both have qualities that could make a partnership if paired up a sort of Ferdinand Vidic set up, We have Fellaini Cahill Neville Heitinga Osman Pienaar Bily Arteta Rodwell who will all be fighting for a place across the middle of the park so something has to give and considering he is a defender by trade it seems it should be a likely outcome?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

cant really see heitinga as a centre back in fact i dont know what position is going to be his best...im still not sure about him hes hard i will give him that and hes got a following on the st end but i want to see him in a settled position.

 

 

 

:blink::blink: That is his peferred position and I think his best performances for us so far have come when he has played at CB

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ive heard senderos is deffo coming and its for a fee of 1.5 million also heard were getting a new board member who has plenty of money....but will he spend it....all gossip but lets just see what happens.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

cant really see heitinga as a centre back in fact i dont know what position is going to be his best...im still not sure about him hes hard i will give him that and hes got a following on the st end but i want to see him in a settled position.

 

 

After watching him against Brum yesterday I don't know how anyone CAN'T see CB as his position, he was immense back there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After watching him against Brum yesterday I don't know how anyone CAN'T see CB as his position, he was immense back there.

His profile on the OS...

 

"He's...one of Hollands's most experienced defenders, racking up nearly 50 caps and occasionally captaining his country before switching to the Toffees.

 

Heitinga can play at both his preferred central defensive role and at right-back, having fulfilled both positions successfully for his country."

That's good enough for me.

 

And we gave him the number five :) . If he's not a center back he shouldn't have got it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heitinga is a natural CB, very similar in style to jags. (see the Heitinga thread for what comparisons i made), and i think with Heitingas obvious ability to pass and Jags leadership and game reading they may make a corker of a pairing when he's back, im excited. Granted it maybe too late by then, but lets hope they work well and look forward to next year eh ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

According to EPL It is reported that Wenger is looking for around £1million for Senderos, after the sale of Lucas not bad £250.000, id have him, if he improves under Moyesy (which he should) him n Jags , move Johnny to RB????

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

According to EPL It is reported that Wenger is looking for around £1million for Senderos, after the sale of Lucas not bad £250.000, id have him, if he improves under Moyesy (which he should) him n Jags , move Johnny to RB????

 

 

No. It's that simple.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

According to EPL It is reported that Wenger is looking for around £1million for Senderos, after the sale of Lucas not bad £250.000, id have him, if he improves under Moyesy (which he should) him n Jags , move Johnny to RB????

 

Why on earth move him to RB Heitinga is a centre back it is his preferred position which he seems damn good at, If Coleman gets given the chance and continue's to be as good as he has looked in the little he's played and Jags gets back to his old self we will without doubt have one of the best back four's in the league, Senderos will make a decent stop gap or squad player.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

True....back to Fanni at RB then,i like Coleman but u know what DM can be like with youngsters,soft spot for Hibbo coz hes longest serving current player at the mo but... not good enough, Neville! not good enough but DM likes him so...good RB and a goalscorer for me

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im half and half with Senderos. Iv seen him play brilliantly and Iv also seen him play shockingly! To me he is a Swiss Yobo and we already have one so Im not sure we need another, especially if they go out of the ANC early!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

According to EPL It is reported that Wenger is looking for around £1million for Senderos, after the sale of Lucas not bad £250.000, id have him, if he improves under Moyesy (which he should) him n Jags , move Johnny to RB????

 

Think im with everyone else on this. Johnny since he's been played in his favoured position at cb has been immense and i cant see any reason to move him from there. On Senderos i don't really rate him not a patch on Johnny or Jags but probably as good or the same as Yobo an Distan.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

According to this website he has signed on loan...

 

http://www.evertonbanter.co.uk/2010/01/everton-agree-loan-deal-for-ar.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+EvertonBanter+%28Everton+Banter%29

 

I dont know how reliable it is but the author seems pretty confident its gone through. I wouldnt mind him on loan as cover, a bit like Gardner was last year. With Heitinga not able to play in the EL and Disitn/Jags not properly fit it makes sense to me.

 

You never know he might surprise us and end up being at the heart of our defence for years to come!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just don't see the logic behind this move, more on Senderos' part than ours. He wants regular first-team football to boost his World Cup chances but he's just not going to get that here.

 

 

To be fair Jags is still out and has been out for such a long period it may take him a bit of time to get back to his beat, Johhny H cant play in Europe, Yobo is injured which only leaves Distin and Duffy

 

Im not a fan of Senderos but I can see why he has brought him in and I think he will get games for us especially in Europe

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not too sure about Senderos's ability, but I think he'll turn out to be a better signing than Jo, at any rate, whether he'll do better then Niell did in his short time here, is open to question. However, we need numbers at the back and looking at the transfer market at the moment there are not that many decent defenders out there with Prem experience. He may not be the best player for us, but I think at the moment, firstly, he could do a job (ie. fill in and backup), and secondly, he may be the better of all evils, considering the players that are available to us in the transfer market.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×