Marco Silva

[MikeO 10,273]

As the original manager thread seems to have vanished without trace (there's no record of anything being done to it in the control panel logs so it's a weird one) I'll start another one. If and when we (Louis) can track it down we'll merge the two. Very strange this, can't recall it ever happening before.

Apologies to all who posted in it.

[Palfy 1,357]

17 minutes ago, MikeO said:

As the original manager thread seems to have vanished without trace (there's no record of anything being done to it in the control panel logs so it's a weird one) I'll start another one. If and when we (Louis) can track it down we'll merge the two. Very strange this, can't recall it ever happening before.

Apologies to all who posted in it.

Fake news Moshiri asked for it to be removed 😉

[Louis 824]

It's gone. 🤷‍♂️

I looked in the database, nothing there. I searched for Silva and found about 10 threads about Anderson da Silva (!) from 2006/2007 (now merged 😀) but the Marcos Silva threads have just disappeared.

[rubecula 886]

4 hours ago, MikeO said:

As the original manager thread seems to have vanished without trace (there's no record of anything being done to it in the control panel logs so it's a weird one) I'll start another one. If and when we (Louis) can track it down we'll merge the two. Very strange this, can't recall it ever happening before.

Apologies to all who posted in it.

not good enough mate  we still have marco but lost his thread?  get yourself sorted out for heavens sake...…  

[rubecula 886]

I thought I had found the original thread but when I tried to click on it I got lickrd off the site  not normal is it?

[rubecula 886]

An error occurred (500 Error)

We're sorry, but a temporary technical error has occurred which means we cannot display this site right now.

php_network_getaddresses: getaddrinfo failed: Name or service not known

You can try again by clicking the button below, or try again later.

[MikeO 10,273]

13 minutes ago, rubecula said:

I thought I had found the original thread but when I tried to click on it I got lickrd off the site  not normal is it?

It has been lost forever sadly, Louis has been on the case and confirmed as much. Quite how is still a bit of a mystery.

[Palfy 1,357]

Can we please have some ideas  on what happened to the Marco Silva thread l’m sure plenty of you have your own thoughts. 

[Matt 5,815]

38 minutes ago, Palfy said:

Can we please have some ideas  on what happened to the Marco Silva thread l’m sure plenty of you have your own thoughts. 

My theory is it imploded under the weight of its own utter ridiculousness 

[MikeO 10,273]

1 hour ago, Palfy said:

Can we please have some ideas  on what happened to the Marco Silva thread l’m sure plenty of you have your own thoughts. 

What will that achieve?

As I said before it's a mystery to those of us with access to the techy stuff, Louis included.

Why would anyone want to sabotage a huge long running thread anyway? We're here to discuss and argue about the minutiae of the Blues after all, it's the raison d'être of the site.

[Cornish Steve 2,574]

I blame Trump.

[Palfy 1,357]

4 minutes ago, MikeO said:

What will that achieve?

As I said before it's a mystery to those of us with access to the techy stuff, Louis included.

Why would anyone want to sabotage a huge long running thread anyway? We're here to discuss and argue about the minutiae of the Blues after all, it's the raison d'être of the site.

Fuck me Mike you had a humour bypass chill out mate. 

 

[Palfy 1,357]

2 minutes ago, Cornish Steve said:

I blame Trump.

And I blame Brexit, second thought it could have been Watford. 

[MikeO 10,273]

2 minutes ago, Palfy said:

Fuck me Mike you had a humour bypass chill out mate. 

It's not a laughing matter for those of us trying to understand what happened.

[Palfy 1,357]

4 minutes ago, MikeO said:

It's not a laughing matter for those of us trying to understand what happened.

Okay Mike I appreciate that just thought it might have been a good opportunity to lighten the mood up, obviously I’ve pissed you off but that wasn’t my intention so I apologise for that. 

[Shukes 2,794]

2 hours ago, Matt said:

My theory is it imploded under the weight of its own utter ridiculousness 

Can we transfer it to the Gana thread please?

[Shukes 2,794]

1 hour ago, Palfy said:

Okay Mike I appreciate that just thought it might have been a good opportunity to lighten the mood up, obviously I’ve pissed you off but that wasn’t my intention so I apologise for that. 

Surprised it’s not Ganas fault!

[Btay 823]

Fresh start for Marco Silva. Ironic given the 17 day ( or something like that )break from games we have.

[London Blue 1,379]

2 minutes ago, Btay said:

Fresh start for Marco Silva. Ironic given the 17 day ( or something like that )break from games we have.

Maybe its a sign, a fresh start for our manager after the break.

I'm just glad the Gana thread was spared this fate..............

 

[Btay 823]

5 minutes ago, London Blue said:

Maybe its a sign, a fresh start for our manager after the break.

I'm just glad the Gana thread was spared this fate..............

 

The old Silva thread was heading down the same dark path though! Fingers crossed this one is bright and full of

“great team selection today”

”wow, another clean sheet”

[London Blue 1,379]

12 minutes ago, Btay said:

The old Silva thread was heading down the same dark path though! Fingers crossed this one is bright and full of

“great team selection today”

”wow, another clean sheet”

Lets hope, to be honest I will settle for rational expectations. 

[Peter H 1,254]

So, Lukaku? Hit or miss? Anyone? Hafnia?

[markjazzbassist 2,115]

I was worried trigger happy moshiri fired him.  I was waiting for the story on sky sports exclusive with his mate jim white “Brands was in Africa scouting a player, a soothsayer told him Silva was hexed, we must get rid, I fired him the next day”

[Palfy 1,357]

2 hours ago, Shukes said:

Surprised it’s not Ganas fault!

😂😂🤣

[Palfy 1,357]

1 hour ago, London Blue said:

Lets hope, to be honest I will settle for rational expectations. 

Would saying we should beat Cardiff and accept any other result as a failure a rational expectation in your view of what a rational expectation should be. 

[rubecula 886]

if we ask niceky  maybe he will come on here and say a few words.  if not we can say a few words to him.  

[Finn balor 1,146]

We get done by Cardiff and Liverpool he has to go. We’re in a shit run of form. I’m giving him these two games. 

[London Blue 1,379]

3 hours ago, Finn balor said:

We get done by Cardiff and Liverpool he has to go. We’re in a shit run of form. I’m giving him these two games. 

Cant judge him on one season, considering the mess he inherited. 

I want him to have a full preseason with players and a second summer transfer window where he and Brands can get a striker (or 2), get a right back to compete with Kenny and get rid of the dead wood.

Once this has happened and the new players have had a chance to settle, and existing players a chance to get their confidence back, then I will be in a better position to judge him.

[nyblue23 534]

4 hours ago, Finn balor said:

We get done by Cardiff and Liverpool he has to go. We’re in a shit run of form. I’m giving him these two games. 

 

12 minutes ago, London Blue said:

Cant judge him on one season, considering the mess he inherited. 

I want him to have a full preseason with players and a second summer transfer window where he and Brands can get a striker (or 2), get a right back to compete with Kenny and get rid of the dead wood.

Once this has happened and the new players have had a chance to settle, and existing players a chance to get their confidence back, then I will be in a better position to judge him.

Unless we’re in a bonafide relegation battle at the very beginning of April (with 6 matches left to play), there’s no way we can sack him.

[Palfy 1,357]

5 hours ago, nyblue23 said:

 

Unless we’re in a bonafide relegation battle at the very beginning of April (with 6 matches left to play), there’s no way we can sack him.

If we are in a proper relegation battle with 6 matches left to play we would have left it to late to sack him, that would be giving the new manager no time to turn it round if we lose to Cardiff he has to go immediately to give someone a chance of turning it around, to expect someone to come in with 6 games to play and save us from relegation is folly.

We have the players to be 7th or at least fighting for it we don't have the manager to take them there.

[London Blue 1,379]

3 hours ago, Palfy said:

If we are in a proper relegation battle with 6 matches left to play we would have left it to late to sack him, that would be giving the new manager no time to turn it round if we lose to Cardiff he has to go immediately to give someone a chance of turning it around, to expect someone to come in with 6 games to play and save us from relegation is folly.

We have the players to be 7th or at least fighting for it we don't have the manager to take them there.

And who would replace him?

[Palfy 1,357]

2 hours ago, London Blue said:

And who would replace him?

Why ask me that that’s what Brands gets paid to find out and if he is as respected in the game as much as we all think he is he shouldn’t have much of a problem finding the right candidate for the job. 

To do nothing to stop the slide into what could quite easily become a relegation spot on the basis you don’t think there’s a manager out there to replace him is crazy, let’s see what happens against Cardiff first we should win comfortably to be honest, but if we lose we will be a very difficult situation with the games coming up, and if we don’t change how do we turn it round because it’s very big and unanimous of people saying give him more time but the club are running out of time to get this right. 

For me lose against Cardiff and he has to go and I think if that does happen a majority of supporters will feel the same way, the risk of hoping he can turn it round will be to great to take on. 

[Matt 5,815]

11 hours ago, nyblue23 said:

 

Unless we’re in a bonafide relegation battle at the very beginning of April (with 6 matches left to play), there’s no way we can sack him.

And what would it achieve if we did?

[FairWooney 71]

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/everton-identity-crisis-prompted-david-15853422.amp

Moyes no

Would Mikel be up for it and do we have any idea if he'd be any good?

He's worked under 2 great managers but never been in charge himself.

I agree that we need to give Silva more time but would be interested in Arteta if he was interested and could impress in interview.  

[nyblue23 534]

4 hours ago, Matt said:

And what would it achieve if we did?

Hopefully give us that jolt that having a new manager tends to give in order to win a few points towards the end of the season. I’m not advocating for his sacking, but we’d pretty much have to lose out through March to be in that position, and if we can’t win a match before April, I’d be pretty worried we wouldn’t win anything in the last six, either without a major change.

Relegation is far from likely at this point, but if it becomes more likely, we’ll need to do everything in our power to stave it off.

[Matt 5,815]

50 minutes ago, nyblue23 said:

Hopefully give us that jolt that having a new manager tends to give in order to win a few points towards the end of the season. I’m not advocating for his sacking, but we’d pretty much have to lose out through March to be in that position, and if we can’t win a match before April, I’d be pretty worried we wouldn’t win anything in the last six, either without a major change.

Relegation is far from likely at this point, but if it becomes more likely, we’ll need to do everything in our power to stave it off.

I know what you mean but I don’t see any other manager going to either take on a sinking ship low on morale. 

[Palfy 1,357]

2 minutes ago, Matt said:

I know what you mean but I don’t see any other manager going to either take on a sinking ship low on morale. 

I don’t know Matt we are big club in my eyes with a lot of potential and  the right ingredients to massively improve where we are at right now, we need to find the right man and I think there will be plenty wanting the opportunity. 

[Matt 5,815]

1 hour ago, Palfy said:

I don’t know Matt we are big club in my eyes with a lot of potential and  the right ingredients to massively improve where we are at right now, we need to find the right man and I think there will be plenty wanting the opportunity. 

We were a big club, we are a big name and there’s great things ahead off field. But for a manager to come in to a club that’s started rotating managers with the wind, a team that’s dereft of confidence and potentially could find themselves in a struggle going on the end of the season, name me one serious candidate that would take this on. 

[duncanmckenzieismagic 4,161]

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/steve-walsh-managerial-uncertainty-who-15860606

[johnh 1,664]

On 17/02/2019 at 18:46, Palfy said:

And I blame Brexit, second thought it could have been Watford. 

It's the Russians.

[Palfy 1,357]

1 hour ago, johnh said:

It's the Russians.

😂

[sydneyneil 57]

We need to get out of the mindset that new managers are put off by the sackings of recent managers. All the top clubs sack managers regularly. Just look at Real....and they can have whoever they want. Im not comparing us to them but for the managers that we can attract, it would always be a good proposition due to the clubs following and finances right now. Money talks, always has and always will.....when Marco Silva got the job Im sure we all agreed that he was a lucky guy to get such a good job and great opportunity.....there's not much difference one season later. 

[Matt 5,815]

3 hours ago, sydneyneil said:

We need to get out of the mindset that new managers are put off by the sackings of recent managers. All the top clubs sack managers regularly. Just look at Real....and they can have whoever they want. Im not comparing us to them but for the managers that we can attract, it would always be a good proposition due to the clubs following and finances right now. Money talks, always has and always will.....when Marco Silva got the job Im sure we all agreed that he was a lucky guy to get such a good job and great opportunity.....there's not much difference one season later. 

Real, Chelsea... they’re already established and stable for the most part, have much bigger coffers and massively better players. Not to mention competing for titles domestic and European. 

We need stablity. Once that’s established we can start the merry go round tactics of managers. But we are at least 5 years away from that. 

[Bailey 3,208]

18 hours ago, sydneyneil said:

We need to get out of the mindset that new managers are put off by the sackings of recent managers. All the top clubs sack managers regularly. Just look at Real....and they can have whoever they want. Im not comparing us to them but for the managers that we can attract, it would always be a good proposition due to the clubs following and finances right now. Money talks, always has and always will.....when Marco Silva got the job Im sure we all agreed that he was a lucky guy to get such a good job and great opportunity.....there's not much difference one season later. 

If managers just keep coming here for the money like Koeman and Allardyce did then we aren't going anywhere fast.

I also wouldnt want to be anything like Chelsea either. Their players used to at least turn up for one season but they cant even do that now. I am fed up with this spineless shower of shit as it is, I wouldnt want to see us paying some of the best players in the league to do exactly the same thing.

[duncanmckenzieismagic 4,161]

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/football/2019/02/22/everton-agree-pay-watford-compensation-4m-avoid-premier-league/

 

Quote

Everton have finally resolved the long-running dispute with Watford over hiring Marco Silva as their manager after agreeing to pay compensation which is understood to be around £4million.

The deal will head off the need for a full independent QC-led inquiry being launched by the Premier League with the organisation having insisted that it wanted the issue sorted out.

Watford made a formal complaint to the Premier League last year believing Silva had been ‘tapped up’ by Everton. The Premier League employed a law firm to interview all the parties involved in the case to establish what should happen next with the hope that a resolution would be reached.

The range of possible sanctions, if the case went to an inquiry and it found against Everton, included a points deduction but the hope was always that it would be settled through a financial arrangement. That has now happened.

 

[Louis 824]

Quote

Everton and Watford can confirm that they have reached an amicable agreement regarding the appointment of Marco Silva as Everton manager last year. Both Everton and Watford are keen to move on from this matter. No further comment will be made.

http://www.evertonfc.com/news/2019/02/22/club-statement

[pete0 1,235]

9 minutes ago, duncanmckenzieismagic said:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/football/2019/02/22/everton-agree-pay-watford-compensation-4m-avoid-premier-league/

Wonder whether we'd have risked the investigation if we had already secured enough points for it not to be a problem. 

The cost of pursuing/hiring Silva is sickening considering the job he's done so far. We've paid extra for Richarlison (£10m I think Brands said), gave fat Sam an extra years wages (£6m) to convince him to stand in, and now £4m on top to avoid the investigation into tapping up Silva. Add an extra £2m for every place dropped from 7th (the expected amount the club would/should have been forecasting). 

It'll be another £6m if we sack him. 

[Finn balor 1,146]

Make that money back alone on Richarlison when he goes

I hope I’m wrong but morishi is not very good at this football lark is he? 

[pete0 1,235]

2 minutes ago, Finn balor said:

Make that money back alone on Richarlison when he goes

I hope I’m wrong but morishi is not very good at this football lark is he? 

Looks like he's finally got it right with Brands but Koeman, Walsh and Silva all seem to have been on his decision and cost an absolute fortune. 

Good thing it's his own money he's throwing away otherwise we'd have been another Portsmouth. 

[MikeO 10,273]

34 minutes ago, duncanmckenzieismagic said:

Everton have finally resolved the long-running dispute with Watford over hiring Marco Silva as their manager after agreeing to pay compensation which is understood to be around £4million.

How much can we counter-sue for under the Consumer Rights Act?

As with the Sale of Goods Act, under the Consumer Rights Act all products must be of satisfactory quality, fit for purpose and as described.  

The rules also include digital content in this definition. So all products - whether physical or digital - must meet the following standards:  

• Satisfactory quality  Goods shouldn't be faulty or damaged when you receive them. You should ask what a reasonable person would consider satisfactory for the goods in question. For example, bargain-bucket products won’t be held to as high standards as luxury goods. 
• Fit for purpose  The goods should be fit for the purpose they are supplied for, as well as any specific purpose you made known to the retailer before you agreed to buy the goods. 
• As described  The goods supplied must match any description given to you, or any models or samples shown to you at the time of purchase.

[Palfy 1,357]

6 minutes ago, Finn balor said:

I hope I’m wrong but morishi is not very good at this football lark is he? 

To put it politely he’s a fucking dick who’s making this club a laughing stock. 

[Finn balor 1,146]

Say what u really mean palf 😂

[London Blue 1,379]

57 minutes ago, Palfy said:

To put it politely he’s a fucking dick who’s making this club a laughing stock. 

Yes, let's be poor, have to sell our best players every year, and have no chance of a new stadium. That sounds much better to me...

[Palfy 1,357]

55 minutes ago, London Blue said:

Yes, let's be poor, have to sell our best players every year, and have no chance of a new stadium. That sounds much better to me...

No let’s not be poor let’s hope he realises he’s out of his depth as an owner and sells up to someone who has a modicum of knowledge, money’s not the end and be all if you haven’t got a clue what your doing with it, an owner with money who’s clueless is worse than an owner who is frugal with his money but makes sure every pound spent is spent wisely, ask Villa fans with this dick we could be easily in the same position. 

[Aidan 1,174]

 Most of us were getting excited to get the DoF who brought in the likes of Drogba, Zola, Mahrez and Kante. Moshiri invested in him, like he promised, and things didn't materialise. 

People slamming him saying he's not very good at running a club, but not many complained when he came in and threw money at Walsh and Koeman. 

He wouldn't have known if the risk would have paid off or not, much like anyone else. However, at least we have an owner who is at least trying to make the right decisions and putting his money where his mouth is. 

His heart is in the right place, and he will seemingly keep trying until he gets it right - which he deserves credit for. 

[hafnia 5,423]

38 minutes ago, Palfy said:

No let’s not be poor let’s hope he realises he’s out of his depth as an owner and sells up to someone who has a modicum of knowledge, money’s not the end and be all if you haven’t got a clue what your doing with it, an owner with money who’s clueless is worse than an owner who is frugal with his money but makes sure every pound spent is spent wisely, ask Villa fans with this dick we could be easily in the same position. 

I disagree Palf....  if he was picking players, tactics, buying and selling them I would agree.  He isn'tt though.... yeah he made a couple of poor appointments managerwise which is his fault but he has bought in brands and from that point I believe manager hiring will be his bag. 

Under kenwright we were nothing.... a team selling our best players, having failed stadium moves, failed investments,  his mate phillip green fleecing us......it take moshiri any day over all that. 

[markjazzbassist 2,115]

49 minutes ago, Palfy said:

No let’s not be poor let’s hope he realises he’s out of his depth as an owner and sells up to someone who has a modicum of knowledge, money’s not the end and be all if you haven’t got a clue what your doing with it, an owner with money who’s clueless is worse than an owner who is frugal with his money but makes sure every pound spent is spent wisely, ask Villa fans with this dick we could be easily in the same position. 

anyone like that already owns a team.  not like some big football guy with billions is sitting out there wondering when some team with court him.  FFS you daft

[Palfy 1,357]

1 hour ago, markjazzbassist said:

anyone like that already owns a team.  not like some big football guy with billions is sitting out there wondering when some team with court him.  FFS you daft

Usmanov is one and there will be others, when Kenwright was looking for a buyer he said he had numerous offers but turned them down until he felt comfortable that who ever he sold too was the right person for the club, fuck me he got that wrong. 

Of course there are big players out there who want to be part of the PL if clubs like ours come available and that’s not daft Mark far from it. 

[markjazzbassist 2,115]

3 hours ago, Palfy said:

Usmanov is one and there will be others, when Kenwright was looking for a buyer he said he had numerous offers but turned them down until he felt comfortable that who ever he sold too was the right person for the club, fuck me he got that wrong. 

Of course there are big players out there who want to be part of the PL if clubs like ours come available and that’s not daft Mark far from it. 

Usmanov doesn’t know shit, he never did anything with arsenal, he is the same as moshiri was there.  Kroenke kept them on the outs and off the board.  he would be learning on the job just like farhad, no difference.

 

next

[Haiku 232]

1 hour ago, markjazzbassist said:

Usmanov doesn’t know shit, he never did anything with arsenal, he is the same as moshiri was there.  Kroenke kept them on the outs and off the board.  he would be learning on the job just like farhad, no difference.

 

next

They don't need to know anything. Do you think Mansour knows how to run a club? These stupid Arab cheikhs can't manage a newspaper kiosk if there isn'tt someone who do it for them.