doesn't have anything to do with playing ability. like saying gazza wasn't great because he's an alcoholic, mutually exclusive.
to my fellow americans re: dempsey v donovan. i think the reason we differ is because i don't care about national team form. when i talk about best player i factor about 90% club playing and only 10% national team. they spend the majority of their lives playing for clubs 38+ matches a season, they play what 10 matches a year with a national side if they're luckY? hence why i choose dempsey, 3rd in premier league scoring, played in england in a proper top league, and has "retired" to the MLS. he's still going too. he's burnout played a ton and he's not quitting. meanwhile donovan played in MLS, did ok for everton no records or insane scoring (against proper competition) and set all sorts of records for the national team while playing trinidad, guatemala, etc. i just can't take that seriously. and then he's gets all wimpy and quits at 32 cause he's tired. you already took a sabbatical, didn't play in the world cup, how are you tired? playing against collegiate USA and central american pros in MLS? Robbie Keane couldn't crack Spurs or Villas lineup week in and week out, goes to MLS and is by and far best player, head and tails above everyone else. That says it right there.
Tim Howard, went to Man United and didn't do we'll, Landon went home from his spell in Europe, Tim was a man, stuck with it and went to a smaller club and kept at it. He's still rocking.