codders78

Silva was the Hull manager when they loaned Niasse so he has worked with him before. He will do for now as much more important areas we need to be spending money on

What happens if Man Utd finish top 4 but also win the Europa league, does that offer the extra champs league place to 5th?

He is the breel deal this kid. His energy could be infectious

I can see the difference but to me coleman is a key player and important if we are building something or at least trying to build something

We can't sell him, not if martinez has sold the dream to stones. It just gives the wrong message, we arent a selling club but go on we will flog arguably the best right back in the prem

He can play no doubt about that. I think he would be an excellent addition and a good replacement if Stones does go. He is ready for that step up and whilst he has the capacity for a mistake or two he will learn and is a work in progress.

Apparently Adem Ljajic is leaving Roma for Aston Villa so might create a need for Roma to sign him

Argentina or uraguay?

I thought his team mate alaverez balanta was the better prospect. Left footed and a bit younger but probably more expensive. I think he will do well for us though

If I had a crystal ball and could see Stones and Jags staying fit all season then I wouldn't want him, he isnt going to improve us and will stand in the way of Galloway, Browning, Holgate getting game time. However if Stones or Jags got a bad one then we would need him but £8mill seems a bit strong for a player out of contract next year and evidently not in the plans of LVG. Would we be prepared to only have 2 established CB's once the window closes? If we could sort something similar to the Barry deal then it could work but would the player want to leave Man Utd to sit on our bench? Perhaps he should join the graveyard of old Utd CB's at Sunderland

I agree. I would like to see him involved more.

No we dont need him. I would have concerns about Besic height to play centre back and thought right back might be more suitable.

Could Besic play right back at a push?

Just thought that. Sorry if I have caused any confusion and made myself look like a knobhead into the bargain

That's not what I said. It isn't as black and white as that. Nobody accepts mediocrity and of course I would like to see some changes at the top of the club, I was merely pointing out that things are not that bad and could be considerably worse, granted they could be considerably better and I fully accept that. We might make a few signings in the coming days and all of a sudden the complexion changes again, of course this could go the other way.