Jump to content

irishtoffee

Members
  • Posts

    171
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by irishtoffee

  1. Now its my turn to realise I havnt explianed myself properly  :unsure: I was acknowledging that it did make a difference, a massive one in fact, I was just saying that it shouldnt have done. The team should be able to cope with a player going off.

    50761[/snapback]

    I understand but does it not concern you to see it looks like we couldn't cope (in terms of defending) on saturdaywhen he went off

  2. sorry lads dont think i explained myself great, i agree the game should have been won before half time and i don't for one second doubt that we weren't the better side but the fact is they got in twice and it isn't a suprise it was when Carsley was off the field. Yes we should have had the game finish by the time Carsley went off but what i meant was if he was on the field i don't think they would have scored their 2 goals. My point was that we are better defending with Cars in front of our center backs.

    Romey said that it shouldn't have made much difference to us when Carsley went off but it did ( from a defensive aspect).

  3. Have to ask this question lads. Do you think we are a better team with Carsley in it?

    In my opinion 100% yes. I really noticed it on saturday when he went off injured, after he went off we looked nervous at the back. I know he isn't the greatest player in the world but we are a far stronger team with Cars sitting in front of the back 4. And i don't believe we have anyone to replace him when he missing, this includes Neville because i know people are going to suggest him.

    On saturday Lee going off injured cost us 3 points. We didn't look to have problems at the back until then. Neville doesn't have the same positional sence as Carsley, he gives 100% but seems to chase after the ball alot and then gets caught out of position creating gaps infront of the center halfs. Any opinions

  4. well emre and parker are hardly world beaters are they?

     

    you'll have to come up better examples than those 2 slackers tbh

    30002[/snapback]

     

    I agree with you about most thing but i dont think you can call Parker a slacker, i remember him being carried off in a game last season because he was phyically sick he ran that much. Not the sign of a slacker, you're right about the turkish ass**** though.

     

    As for emerton - would be a slight improvement on Kilbane but slight improvement ins't good enough - Pass on this one, anyway looks like the wonderful VDM wants to stay again <_<

×
×
  • Create New...