sydneyneil

It’s an obvious comparison but when Balotelli had a reputation for being very talented and he just needed  to sort his disciplinary problems out, I just could never see this supposed talent.

i think I saw him have one good game, an international against England in about 5 years yet the media portrayed him as this troubled soul with immense potential. Could never see it myself, he always looked bang average at best. Keans not played much but I just don’t see it?? Maybe it’s Italian journalists......

This lads talent has been exaggerated from day one. The only talent we should be nurturing right now is the boss in the dugout 

41 minutes ago, Finn balor said:

Fucking sky are doing a report on silva and  are accusing our fans of singing during the Norwich game your getting sacked in the morning 

No accusation necessary that’s exactly what happened

It's a results orientated business. That's a fact. He's the polar opposite to Sam Allardyce. Sam is hated but gets results. He knows how to organise teams and manages games well, sees games out, seemingly with a worse squad than what Silva has right now. (I'm not advocating for BFS here, just making a point!)

Silva is actually well liked as a bloke and he tries to play attacking football but it's far too kamikaze and his in game management is the worst Ive ever seen. Zero organisational skills which is mirrored in his results. His win percentage in the Premier League is woeful and it is getting worse....Does anyone think he would have had Watford relegated if he would have continued?

Probably, and that is a huge cause for concern. This guy manages teams in a relegation fight and has lost one already. The next club got rid before they were sucked in. Please don't let us make that fateful mistake......

He looks like the type of player opponents would be worried about and that's why he should play more minutes. Especially away from home. Todays and Wednesdays game are ideal for him.

I'm a big Digne fan but he's been targeted a few times this season and today was one of them. He's gets bullied a bit by anyone with pace and he gets passed too easily.

Great going forward no doubt but not the best defensively. I actually think we could do with a Baines in the team right now. I wouldnt swap him for Digne right now but his composure on the ball and leadership would surely bode well in games like todays from 80 mins on. Why does he never even get brought on?

We can blame injuries, VAR, or whatever else but his game management is so poor. Every match at the end, usually when in the balance, he likes to turn it into a basketball game, and we lose every time. There's just no composure. We need someone to put their foot on the ball and take the sting out of it. Instead, we are lumping balls to our outlets trying to hit them on the counter. It's just back and forth. It's not the players, it's his instructions and how we play every single week. It's no coincidence, or luck that we concede and lose games late on so often.

He is out of his depth as a premier league manager. The best managers get the luck and the worst managers don't seem to get any. It's how it works and Marco Silva already has a relegation on his resume. I do believe that in the end, Hull were a tad unlucky to go down that year after a great revival. He just has that knack and we need him out asap.

Nice bloke though....

I’ll look back at this guy with fond memories. I’ll remember him for making some of the worst subs I’ve ever seen. I’ll also think “remember how we never came back from a goal down over 18 months!”

then I’ll think of how many goals we concede from set plays and wonder how he kept his job for so long....

We will wait until we are in the bottom three then before we start panicking? Is that the case? Oh it’s ok, Brands is here. The guy who did well in the same league that Steve McLaren won. This current set up will relegate us make no mistake

Well hopefully. We really need to lose this “if he wins this or loses this” mentality which is telling us whether or not he should be sacked. He’s 100% not the right guy for the job whether or not he beats Leicester or Liverpool. It’s this thought process which holds us back. Looking at arsenal from the outside, emery wasn’t the right guy. Progress wasn’t being made. Yes you can pick up the odd win but that shouldn’t distort the overall picture. People say Silva has been unlucky but he’s managed to win those games that were must win games to avoid a crisis. Those wins every now and again just before crisis point has kept him in the job longer than he should be.

His comments today are embarrassing. Did he not hear the chants towards Silva last week? Good to see his expectations are as mediocre as the rest of the board. So out of touch with the fans it’s unbelievable. This guy could be the main reason Silva’s still in the job....

As you can see from previous posts I’m certainly not a huge brands fan from his transfer dealings. If Moyes does get appointed, then Brands stock will fall with many fans. I don’t get who makes these decisions though.

Moyes would surely be a Kenwright appointment. We have far too many chefs right now all involved in the decision process. Brands, from what I understand, is heavily involved dealing with Silva on a daily basis identifying transfer targets, discussing player profiles and how this fits into a style of play. Is that right? Is he also supposed to be scouring Europe, drawing up a list of managerial targets with agents for when the current guy doesn’t work? Sounds a bit weird to me. Surely a good relationship between the DOF and manager is crucial. We hear how koeman and Walsh hated each other so that was never going to work. How are you supposed to have a good trusting relationship with the manager if you’re constantly on the look out for his replacement? It could even be this relationship which is delaying the inevitable sacking of Silva right now?

i understand that other clubs have this model and it’s been successful. Liverpool and city spring to mind but they have the two best managers in the world so I’m fairly sure that’s why the model works.

who is tottenhams DOF? Do they have one? Daniel levy makes the big decisions there that’s for sure. If they do have one I’ve never heard him mentioned. Levy hires and fires and signs the cheque’s. Jose will certainly be the biggest influencer in the transfer targets and signing of players without a doubt. It’s simple. And it works.

We have a new majority shareholder allowing the previous majority shareholder to still be involved in the decisions and hang around with his influence. Then we have a DOF getting lost in all of the craziness above him. Just a really, really badly ran football club.

It’s just a terribly run football club. Everything we do has no planning or organisation. Nothing we do is proactive. Guess what, the same club that every single year is scrambling round on deadline day looking for signings or loan deals is doing exactly the same thing with the manager. Just embarrassing

I believe it’s happening tomorrow. 

31 minutes ago, TallPaul1878 said:

The relationship between the DoF and the manager/coach is all wrong.

How I understand it is that a manager makes the final decision on new players and contracts whereas a coach just prepares the team for and during matches. So Silva is a head coach whereas Moyes previously was a manager.

I don't think the current system works at a club like Everton because we are still trying to punch above our weight and need some bloody mindedness. I think the demands are too different to European clubs or the clubs at the top of the league.

We need a manager who can identify weaknesses in his team and produce a profile for the players that he requires. Then Brands should go and find some of those players for the manager. Currently it seems that Brands is deciding what players we need and then the coach is just preparing them for games.

Who knows. Everyone else tells me the DOF model works at other clubs like Liverpool and city. There’s no way in a million years there’s another person telling klopp or guardiola who to buy and how to play football. Why do we think that brands is a mastermind behind all our transfers? I question everything because I haven’t got a clue. The DOF is only important when you have a crap manager.....

38 minutes ago, TallPaul1878 said:

Because, the impression I get is that, Brands has his own ideas of which players he wants to bring in but Moshiri wants to make some big statement signings. Brands has been brought in to operate the club in a certain way but then Moshiri has his own input and desires a big name signing to promote the club. This is what made the previous transfer window a calamity after looking like a promising start.

The problem is that football clubs shouldn't really be operated like a business but more like an army. A football club, like an army, must win at all costs. The business side of things is just to facilitate this aim.

Moshiri should concentrate on the financial side of things and ensure that the results are proportionate to the amount of money being spent. The actual football side of things should be left to the playing staff. You wouldn't have a politician suggesting to his generals how to fight a war or which troops to deploy!

The important quote here is “the impression I get” which means that we don’t know. No one knows who is in charge of buying players and hiring or sacking of managers at this club and it’s being run disgracefully. Either way, Silva is not the right man for Everton and someone needs to get rid of him. Whoever that is....

Suits. Also......”director of football at a club that plays crap football, can’t do no wrong, getting paid loads, has a season to identify a right back and gets a Monaco reject, who can’t defend, gets no centre half, buys some kid who’s hardly played pro football to lead a premier league team line, buys a crock from city who even when he does play is always 80%, but really carries himself well” so let’s just say he’s quality anyway and hope the next managers amazing to cover up this guys fraudulent perception 

Marcel “buy crap players, Silva gets slaughtered (rightly - I’m his worst fan), let Silva take all the blame, then let moshiri take the blame for not sacking him, have zero to do with any names getting mentioned in replacing him, wear nice hits. Say f all to the press, buy iwobi for 40 mill, whack in a cheeky bid for zaha” brands.

what a guy 

Why do people keep on saying brands Is the guy to hire and fire but then slag moshiri off...too many chefs here

He’s crap this fella but really no worse than the other lot around him. Just gets lynched more  because of his gait and demeanour. Mina and sig were dreadful for both goals today and I can’t think of one player who was average. Even our annoying goalkeeper makes a good save but then boots the ball out about fifteen times because he thinks he’s pirlo 

Strong rumours it will be Moyes. He was also interviewed prior to allardyces appointment so it’s certainly on their minds. Moyes as interim with a chance to go perm....

He should have gone last year. I’ve seen no signs of progress whatsoever. The football is utter drivel. This brands getting a free ride off some too. That summer business was garbage. Had 70 mill of it on the bench today (iwobi is average at best btw), one doesn’t even come on, and the right back he’s had a season to find is a woeful defender. He’s getting pulled after an hour to bring a finished Seamus back on. Just stinks the club from top to bottom. 

Been disappointed with this guy. I didn't think he was going to be great really though when people just kept on talking about a team talk he did on some doco.....

He's being unlucky with injuries but hes being lucky in that that probably keeping him in his job. The Gomes injury masked another poor performance today. Just no ideas going forward we are so slow with the ball. Next week a nailed on draw to get him through the international break before the dreaded December......

He looks a slight improvement on Coleman but he just doesn't seem to have the pace required for me to be a top premier league full back. Sometimes he dwells a bit on the ball too but maybe that will improve in time. I'm not convinced that he was the first choice RB we were after in the summer.