where did i say i want neville or carsley to play?
i want jags in the midfield, i want cahill next to him, i want arteta out on the right and i want a wide player for the left side too.
look at the formation, theres 3 down the middle so a ball winner isnt needed.
then why put one in there?
every great team has one, they always have and they always will.
Real Madrid got mugged big time when they thought they got themselves a ball winner!
Jags can do that job fine!
if you want to play that formation (which is a formation i like by the way) we used manny as the wide left against watford last year and it worked. it is the formation i think we should use while we have no wingers, but id just use different players than you.
-------------Jags-------------
Grav------Cahill-----Arteta
or
--------------Jags-------------
Pienaar----Cahill-----Arteta
EDIT:
just a final note, before you keep bringing neville and carsley into it; read my post! no mention of neville or carsley, but your putting a ball winner in your side, for some reason you think i want it to be cars or nev, thou ive posted many times how impressive jags is in the midfireld! and the harm in having grav on his own in the middle comes from the many times that we all saw him leave massive space in the middle due to his headless chicken attacking style. (note; grav is an attacking player, and an attacking player only!)