scouse

Howards Way :-)

thought Utd only wanted to sell, cant see him going on loan, Jose said already if he stays he will play.

it depends what one you get, if the lad actually applied himself he would be some player, his talent is there just attitude sucks for that I cant see it happening.

if we sign him it just shows we are not getting our real targets

would love him here would have loved to have had a gamble when he left Utd was around 10 mill?

100%

more McCarthy than Barry but not electric pace

I think at the time we where more attractive, he still wants to work with Koeman but wont pick us over City. (not apples with apples I know)

Agree with everyone here - would be a great signing for us and add real strength to our backline and be a perfect partner for Williams.

Would love him here, if Swans sell probably means relegation for them so cant see it unless he forces the issue.

This has transfer deadline day move all over it sadly but hopefully think he would be good for us.

whats wrong with that, I thought everyone done that so my wife said anyway

Hope so just for this :-)

if that was to believed in the summer we would be a team of superstars!

thought this would go when Martinez left!

irritating but well within there rights and probably doing the right thing for themselves they had huge outlay in the summer so trying to claw back as much as they can (I know wages plays into this)

We should have had him in for Leicester match - result probably would have been different and worst case he would be a match into his career ahead of City. Throwing in a player against City that has not even done a full week of training with his new club could kill us. I can understand Koeman's frustrations and if we don't bring in at 4 first team players for Jan I fear for Koeman's long term future with us.

as said previously we missed the boat when he left Celtic

no one is saying he is bad, and would he get in our team probably yes. however is he one of the best defenders in the league I dont think so.

agreed think he will go to Utd

have to agree and agree we should be aiming higher than Keane and Gibson aswell.

Fonte handed in transfer request interesting times!

always mooted as the next big thing, the fact he never moved on says it all. doubt he is better than what we already have.

Still think its an area we need to strengthen, neither keeper instils me with confidence especially given our back 4 are not rock solid

think this will be done before EOW, needs time to settle plus he hasn't played match for sometime so will need time to come upto speed, thankfully he wont need to adapt to Koemans style!. excited by this deal him and Gana will be a solid pairing in the middle hopewe pull it off. Agree think 22.5 will be the price aswell!