Who Would You Rather Have?

[Adams]

1) Nugent or R.keane

2) Sidwell or Barton

 

who would you rather have?

[aaron]

Keane and Sidwell. both very good. Nugent isnt proved in Prem so is a gamble really, most likely a premstar in a few years, but keane has experiance and scores quiet a few a season. Sidwell is a very very good midfielder, just what we should be looking for in the summer, keeps his head down and gives 100% every time ive seen him play, plays nice passes, tackles wel and scores, barton on the other hand is a very good player but antics let himself down.

Edited April 7, 2007 by Everton Lad

[StevO]

id take any of the four! but if i had to chose id have keane and barton

[Romey 1878]

Keane and Barton hands down. How anyone could choose Sidwell ahead of Barton is beyond me.

[Dunny the Blue]

Nugent - Sidwell, I think Nug is immense and I'm holding my own personel grudges against Barton as I think he's well..... A COCK!!

[Heather_6]

keane and i cant decide between barton or sidwell

[Joe]

Keane and Barton in a second. I think Keane would work very well upfront with AJ but I can't see him coming to Everton. Barton is an amazing player. He does a great job controlling the game and he is the single reason why City won't be relegated this year. I rate him very high.

[J*A*C*K*E*L*Z]

sidwell and keane everytime proven goal scorrer at every level but nugent for playing with johnson otherwise you might get a defoe keane thing going on with doesnt work at all.