Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Guest Reg Reagan

Cahill Better Than Kewell

Recommended Posts

Guest Reg Reagan

former skippies coach rale rasic and ex skippies captain robbie slater reckon that tim cahill is better than harry kewell!

 

"if anything, hes too modest for what hes achieving," said rasic, "You know that whenever he takes the field something happens. His second goal was just unbelievable and world class"

 

Robbie Slater agrees with Rasic, "Look, Kewell gets a lot of publicity and is a gifted player when hes fit. But the truth the fact of a matter is that harry kewell plays for liverpool and if he played any other club like Everton, man utd or middlesborough, i can guarantee you will see the best of kewell."

 

"Harry had one good shot which just grazed over the cross bar straight after japan scored and kewell can be one of those impact players as we have seen in the World Cup Qualifiers against Uruguay" said Slater, "that night was kewells night and yesterday was chaills day"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Scored a beauty against Everton ;) and won a CL and FA Cup winners medal. Seriously, my point was that comparing players that play in different positions is for plebs. This comparasion is based on the fact that both are Aussies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If they both went up for sale tomorrow, its Cahill who would fetch the higher fee. Kewells on the way Down, Cahills on the way up. :)

 

I´d say if Cahill scores afew more he`s on the way out!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Scored a beauty against Everton ;)   and won a CL and FA Cup winners medal. Seriously, my point was that comparing players that play in different positions is for plebs. This comparasion is based on the fact that both are Aussies.

 

I get your point but compare them on the basis of who creates the most impact for club & country and who would be looked upon as the more important member of a squad and for me Cahill wins hands down every time!

 

Kewell has got a good shot and can pass the ball well but his injury problems & inconsistancy make him a liability. I never realy rated him at Leeds either he just scored a few fancy goals but if i remember rightly so did Mark Viduka and whats he done since? Sweet FA!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I get your point but compare them on the basis of who creates the most impact for club & country and who would be looked upon as the more important member of a squad and for me Cahill wins hands down every time!

 

Kewell has got a good shot and can pass the ball well but his injury problems & inconsistancy make him a liability. I never realy rated him at Leeds either he just scored a few fancy goals but if i remember rightly so did Mark Viduka and whats he done since? Sweet FA!!

 

I think Cahill is a good player and certainly has a lot of drive and passion, which I admit HK is short of. But I think HK is a more skillful player. Tbh, I don`t think there`s a big difference if you evaluate them on an overall basis.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
:lol: this thread is funny

 

Heh are you a red shite supporter?

........................................

 

He is, but that doesnt ban him from passing his opinion so dont let it develop into a slanging match.

We try to encourage fans from other teams onto the forum, and as long as they play by the rules, they are welcome.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
:lol: this thread is funny

 

Heh are you a red shite supporter?

 

 

Yes, this site was recommended to me by bluetex, who is a good friend of mine (despite being a blue), he was attracted by the "thinking evertonian" bit, which I admired until I read a few Reg Regan posts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

that doesnt go for us all heh, i am happy for any fan of football to be here, as long as everyone knows were the line is, at the end of the day it is an Everton forum and opinions may differ from you own alot :D

 

as for the actual thread, i agree with you its hard to compare position to position but at the minute you have to say that cahill is looking the more valuable and up coming player out of the two, i rated kewell when he was at leeds but his heart seemed to have gone out of it when he signed for use, injuries getting him down possibly?

 

he has returned to some kind of form but IMO i would rather have cahill in the team then kewell

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
was attracted by the "thinking evertonian" bit, which I admired until I read a few Reg Regan posts.

 

His posts are on a different 'thinking' level, us mere mortals will never understand that level :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
His posts are on a different 'thinking' level, us mere mortals will never understand that level :lol:

29449[/snapback]

:) this is simple timmy the great :D kewell the crap,its simple logic ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can't see us getting 15m for timmy 8 I reckon max but I don't reckon he is going anywhere anyway. On the Kewell debate at least he has got rid of his double ponytail thing that he had going on that was just stupid

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's my last fm account, not sure if you know about it but its a plugin that works with Winamp or media player or iTunes or whatever you use to listen to music and records your musical tastes it's pretty cool I have had an account for about a year but only added the sig today. I recommend signing up it's free and all www.lastfm.com Anyway I'll stop plugging it now

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Kewell can play in different positions. He's better in the middle than Cahill, why? Cahill scores more goals, Kewell can score (not as much than Cahill) but he creates and is one of the better 'keeper of the ball'.Very rarely does he give the ball away.

 

You say he didnt deserve the CL and the FA Cup medal? That is 'absolute bollox'. Just because he could contribute in the final doesnt mean that he doesnt desrve the medal. His contribution against Olympiacos was immense. Steve got all the credit because he scored the 'wondergoal', steve had a poor game. Kewell was immense, easily the MOTM.

Against Juve, Chelsea when we were 1-0 up with only little time to go, Cisse was brought on and couldnt hold the ball up and ended losing it. When Kewell was brought on, he kept the ball and won important freekicks and basically took most of the pressure from us. His role was as important as Luis Garcia's goals against Juve and Chelsea.

 

He played in most (all?) of our F.A. Cup games and had major roles till the final. Knocking him off because his groin flared up in those finals is taking away the job Kewell did for us in both competitions.

 

And i dont believe that Cahill is better than Kewell. He might score more goals but thats it. He doesnt create much and is not a great passer at all. Arteta is your best midfielder. If you get 6 million for Cahill i'd be surprised, 8 million is way too much.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good points.......slightly biased. but arent we all. :)

 

 

you say we wouldnt get 8m, but might get 6m for Cahill. OK.

 

how much would you get for Kewell. ??????

 

ones on the way up the others on the way down. :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If i question or argue i'm a "bitter blue"!

 

Dont agree, neither does the very experienced manager who manages both of them in the national team but as 5 times european champions liverpool fans are as always all knowing and most of all never wrong.

 

Question how do liverpool fans drive cars safely when all they ever see is red?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I´d say if Cahill scores afew more he`s on the way out!

29430[/snapback]

 

and who wud he go 2... someone lyk manure or arsenal, and at least we will get all the transfer fee paid for him not just a little bit... mm wonder who done that :rolleyes: cahill is a better player then kewell read the first post on this topic says it all, and theres one big difference.. cahill plays for Everton so hes much better :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just heard Cahill is off to Manure for £9million after the world cup, its already a done deal apparently

29612[/snapback]

 

Stop it i want evidence before i'm believing anything like this. Everyone in the world is gona start a Cahill story after that performance and none of them will be true :angry:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kewell can play in different positions. He's better in the middle than Cahill, why? Cahill scores more goals, Kewell can score (not as much than Cahill) but he creates and is one of the better 'keeper of the ball'.Very rarely does he give the ball away.

 

You say he didnt deserve the CL and the FA Cup medal? That is 'absolute bollox'. Just because he could contribute in the final doesnt mean that he doesnt desrve the medal. His contribution against Olympiacos was immense. Steve got all the credit because he scored the 'wondergoal', steve had a poor game. Kewell was immense, easily the MOTM.

Against Juve, Chelsea when we were 1-0 up with only little time to go, Cisse was brought on and couldnt hold the ball up and ended losing it. When Kewell was brought on, he kept the ball and won important freekicks and basically took most of the pressure from us. His role was as important as Luis Garcia's goals against Juve and Chelsea.

 

He played in most (all?) of our F.A. Cup games and had major roles till the final. Knocking him off because his groin flared up in those finals is taking away the job Kewell did for us in both competitions.

 

And i dont believe that Cahill is better than Kewell. He might score more goals but thats it. He doesnt create much and is not a great passer at all. Arteta is your best midfielder. If you get 6 million for Cahill i'd be surprised, 8 million is way too much.

29574[/snapback]

 

Maybe kewell did contribute alot but saying he is a better central midfielder is ludicrous(cant spell) cahill is a better tackler, more energy, more passion, scores more, upsets apponents, can keep the ball and is a good passer believe it or not, kewell may be a better winger but saying he is abetter central midfielder is utter nonsense.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just heard Cahill is off to Manure for £9million after the world cup, its already a done deal apparently

29612[/snapback]

 

were did you here this? its not on sky sports news or fansfc .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Toffeeweb

29656[/snapback]

 

Reliable then :lol:

 

Everton stories can neva be believed, how does a website know when David, Bill & Kieth aint even got a clue when they get to work in the morning?

 

Timmy stays if we were gona sell him we would do the deal now freeing cash to replace him. We wont loose one of our bets players with no time to replace him that lesson was learned with Rooney i hope.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thats bullshit, my uncle is a taxi driver and he picked him up last season, all he could say was his love for Everton football club and the city. With him probly now made friends in liverpool i dont think he would want to fuck off to the scum but yano money makes un-usual things happen :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

true, i dont think a cahill type player is needed there tho expecially when they have went in for the likes of Carrick, Zokora, Mascherano etc there all defensive minded players but ya never no with football these days mate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Scored a beauty against Everton ;)   and won a CL and FA Cup winners medal. Seriously, my point was that comparing players that play in different positions is for plebs. This comparasion is based on the fact that both are Aussies.

29414[/snapback]

Ur the fekinb pleb mate

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lets hope he sticks to what he said and doesnt do a Rooney

29765[/snapback]

 

At the end of the day money talks and if manure offer efc 8mil and cahil 50K a week hes off.

 

regarding he fact that they want a defensive midfielder, manure are always looking to strengthen their squad and a bit light in the midfield

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×