Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Sickboy

Kilbane?

Should he ever play for us again?  

28 members have voted

  1. 1. Should he ever play for us again?

    • Yes, He's a great player who deserve's the cheque every week
      3
    • No, He's a oxygen theif. Get rid of him NOW!!!!
      25


Recommended Posts

After watching the match and marvaling at the shear passion, commitment, control & passing that is the KEVIN KILBANE show, i got to thinking, Should he ever pull on a blue shirt again or should we give the number 14 to 1 of the women from the ladies team who are 2nd in their league?

Your thoughts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Zed    1

They were all shite, lets not look for scapgoats, and start pointing the finger at killer, if moyes thought there was an individual better then he would have played him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Zed    1

They were all shite, lets not look for scapgoats, and start pointing the finger at killer, if moyes thought there was an individual better then he would have played him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ian    3

kilbane is a good squad player, decent for cover. as everyone else has been sayin u cannot blame one man for a performance like that, shocking

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
They were all shite, lets not look for scapgoats, and start pointing the finger at killer, if moyes thought there was an individual better then he would have played him.

its not a case of looking for scapegoats more often then not kilbane plays shite personally i would like to see kilbane/wright/pistone leave the club

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, He's a great player who deserve's the cheque every week [ 0 ] [0.00%]

No, He's a oxygen theif. Get rid of him NOW!!!! [ 14 ] [100.00%]

 

 

looks like somone is well likes here !!!!!!!!!!! :(

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we did a poll on all our players, there's not that many who would get the "he deserves his cheque" vote. I think Kilbane is just one of many who are not performing, but like every team who go through bad patches, the fans are quick to make someone a scapegoat.

It seems that Poor old Killa is ours, last time it was Unsworth, but it could quite easily be Beattie, Bent, Weir, Martyn, in fact tell me.....WHO IN THE SQUAD IS PLAYING WELL. ????

 

Time to bring some fresh blood in, Turner, Vaughan, Ferrari,Valente, Kroldrop,

These players must be introduced. the team have had long enough and are not doing it. If we did our jobs as badly, You or i would have been sacked before now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The whole team is to blame for the blunder that was saturday.

 

Unfortunately kilbane made the cock up of all cock ups.

 

the team lost the ball from each kick-off (they had 5!) and we couldnt even clear our lines - hence the 3rd goal - Martyn had no chance, weir and yobo let the little fucker shoot!

 

Anyway - try not to pick out scapegoats - arteta was shit, VDm was shit, BT was shit, Hibbert was shit, Neville was shit - get the drift.

 

the performance was a joke and i hope moyesy has fined a few players for it!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Kilbane is not a scapegoats he was worse than anyone on the pitch. In my opinion.

 

His passing all though the game was terrible.

 

It just happened that the back pass was just the icing on the cake for his bad game.

 

i agree with you that the whole team played bad but Kilbane really was teffible.

 

Have never said before that Kilbane was not good enough but had Cahill been fit can't see him starting and you can understand why.

 

A fringe player at best at the moment. Don't think he crossed the ball in once in the game

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In any sort of deal as a buyer, you only get what you pay for. both kilbane, and bent, along with martyn, where all bought on the cheap, and struck me as being panic buys. We either had no money or not enough time to look for anything better.

Lucky for us that martyn turned out as the better of them all, but father time is catching up on him too.

 

PS......forgot about the pistone U turn, another panic deal that has'nt worked out.

 

Need to clear out all the deadwood and bring our youngsters in for some match practice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
EVA    0

I agree that it's the time to try out on out youth. Other teams also bring in young players at the age of 18-20. Why not give ours a try before the transfer windows re-opens in January? Shall we just loan out more of them in lower leagues for better preparation?

 

Btw, I think Osman plays okay that day. At least he is the only midfielder that day who can put in a decent straight passs which cut deep into the "right" penalty area for our forwards.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I agree that it's the time to try out on out youth.  Other teams also bring in young players at the age of 18-20.  Why not give ours a try before the transfer windows re-opens in January?  Shall we just loan out more of them in lower leagues for better preparation?

 

Btw, I think Osman plays okay that day.  At least he is the only midfielder that day who can put in a decent straight passs which cut deep into the "right" penalty area for our forwards.

It will be time for youth when we are playing Leeds in the championship and all our players have got up and left. Although, judgin by their top performance against WBA, I doubt any premiership side will have any Everton players.

 

I think that kilbane did have a terrible game - but look at mOyesy's options...

 

Had any left back been fit, then Kilbane would have been on the bench...Neville would have filled the midfield gap.

 

Unfortunately, we have the majority of our first team defence (in my opinion) out on the injury table..

 

My defence would be....

 

Hibbo Yobo Kroldrup/Ferrari Valente/Ferrari

 

So - he had little option but to play Kilbane and put VDM on the right - VDM was poor and hardly called for the ball. It was not good.

 

Having said that - even kilbane should be able to see off any RB at WBA - but it wasn't to be and I hope to god that Moyesy bollocked everyone of those players as soon as the final whistle sounded - and then bollocked them again back at bellefield - and fined ALL of them for a lack of ambition and effort.

 

Cheeky bastards - i paid good, hard earned money to watch that game! Getting beat is one thing, not putting the effort in is unacceptable.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

But Rowlo....he didnt HAVE to bring kilbane in, VDM and ARTETA could have stayed on the wings. He had the options to bring just one player into midfield.

 

I'm beginning to question DMs knowledge on Team selection and Tactics, cos i think he's making a right pigs ear of it lately.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
But Rowlo....he didnt HAVE to bring kilbane in,  VDM and ARTETA could have stayed on the wings. He had the options to bring just one player into midfield.

 

I'm beginning to question DMs knowledge on Team selection and Tactics, cos i think he's making a right pigs ear of it lately.

What would your team have been - provided that:

 

Ferrari, Valente, Cahill, Naysmith, Ferguson

 

Could all not be picked to start the game...

 

Mine would have been...

(taking a risk)

 

..............................Martyn.................................

 

Hibbo........Yobo..................Wier.................Kroldrup

 

Arteta...........Davies...........Neville.............VDM

 

...............BT..........................Bent....................

 

 

Subs

 

Osman,

Ferguson,

Wright

McFadden

Kilbane

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mine would have been same team as previous two games, just needed to bring in Osman , for the missing Cahill. NO disruption to the rest of the team.

 

But that was last week, this week KROLDROP must come in for Weir, ASAP.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
is Kroldrup fit enough to start yet?

He is fully fit but he has not got any 'match fitness' - he hasn't played english football yet (excluding crappy reserves outings) - I thought that Moyes would have used him as a sub by now to get him fit - but no.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest fozzie22   
Guest fozzie22
He is fully fit but he has not got any 'match fitness' - he hasn't played english football yet (excluding crappy reserves outings) - I thought that Moyes would have used him as a sub by now to get him fit - but no.

If i where more cycnical :) i could swear i could see the beginings of a nipple coming thru DMs head when he's talking tactics

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Foz........

"If i where more cycnical i could swear i could see the beginings of a nipple coming thru DMs head when he's talking tactics"

 

..............

 

:):lol::huh:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×