robin.jones

I have seen alot of comments about 4-4-2 and 4-5-1 I personally would go with the latter. But given each one who would you choose for your 2/3 players in the middle. I am not asking for the whole midfield because I think it's a given that Arteta and Piernar would get the nod. Anyway I think 4-4-2 the CM should be cahill and carsley. as I think cars is the best water carrier and timmy is the best at getting forward . I think this put's alot of pressure on arteta to be creative. In a 4-5-1 I would go with Cahill cars and osman. Cahill and cars for the same reason as above and osman for his ability to pick the ball up of the defence and actually do something with it. I have been really impressed with ossie in the middle over the last 2 games.

I haven't seen jags at right back but I am happy to go with the majority of views taht he is best option in the current squad. Although I will always have a soft spot for hibbo as a local boy coming through the ranks.

I like faddy and this season he has started ok but he is 25 and since signing he has never been able to do it consistently. I actually think a move abroad to somwheer like france/ spain where they get more space would be the making of him. I also think he has been a good servant to the club and I think staying with us would hold him back. Add to that we could probably get 3-5 mil for him and I would be happy that.

Moyes will play what gets results and 442 hasn't worked enough. With cahill back we have won 3 in 3 all be it in separate competitions. I think withy cahill fit we have to stick to 451 and given a choice with everyone fit I would have to go for AJ up front. I like all our stikers and they all give us something different and it's a shame we can't play 442 but cahill is our best player and 451 get's the best out of him. As much as I rate him I think faddy is never goign to work in a team like everton and he should be sold.

I am really torn at the moment we are soo much better in a 451 but how are we goign to keep all our stikers happy. I would stick with Yak as I would like to see him start scoring.

I think we should stick to 451 with Big Vic up front. I am worried we aren't the best at 442 and now have 5 good strikers fighting for potentially 1 place

Will he get a game when AJ is fit again? as much as I want their partnership to work we played so well in euroope with a 451 it would make no sense to go back the other way.

don't get me started. I actually think neville was dropped does anyone know why?

Did anybody else get the sense that with more quality on the pitch as appose to saturday it spured everyone on to play better. Hibbo game was much better going forward. Osman and Cars look much more willing and able with cahill in the team. It's amazing what a lift he has given us. Even spuddy put in a better performance than he has in ages. Spud and toomy G playing it to each other on the wing was fantastic.

Is that real if so the FA have to take a look at that.

Neville isn't up to it!

Best passing display I have seen form an everton team all season. Does moyes tell them to play long ball ?? surely not. We played in on the floor and with players like piernar cahill osman who can keep it we looked amazing. Carsley for our best player. I also think it was good to see a CM like Osman drop deep to pick the ball up- off the defence we should play the same team against Derby and hammer them. My other thoughts are about faddy he isn't a loan striker and I would wonder wether Yak can play that roll either. I think AJ VIC and JV can defo play in a 451 so lets push on.

Sorry to labout a point but Kipper provides no direct quote so a cut of the exact words would be useful?

the way our current midfield is he must be given a chance.

I have been looking on the FA website and we can make a formal complaint to the FA about Clatterknob's handling of the derby game. I am not sure whether this complaint is best coming from 100's of individuals or from the chairmen of the supporters club. We should also complain about Rafa post match comments which were inciteful between the two sets of fans. Whats your thoughts. Also doesn anyone know who employs the ref's for the games is it the prem or the FA.

Can you provide a link or a direct quote from the book that they are freinds.

Again I harp back to the point about creativityand the lack of over the last 3 months. We have in the squad a player like VDM who on his day could change a game if we keep him we play him when required and fod Funk sake he has been required in some of the awful displays I have seen. Moyes needs to put up or shut up. Baines again why has he been dropped he hasn't put a foot wrong. WHATS THE OBSESSION WITH PLAYING THE LONG BALL GAME

It does seem to be the case jags is lacking somewhere I think a realistic option would be a 451 now timmy is back and get back to winning ways

I would like to see both of them blooded so they are ready if baines is injured. and for times like this when we need someone in midfield with some creativity.

Radical Idea and I know we like 451 or 442 but I would like to goad opinion on this option with the players we have. Howard. Jags (RCB) Yobo (CB) Lescott (LCB) Nev (RWB) Baines (LWB) Carsley (DM) Arteta Cahill AJ YAk I think in this formation we can the best out of all these players. I would still look to replace neville at righ-wing back but for now he would be the best option.

As much As I want to think moyes has more in his locker. This season I do have to question the tactics he has been playing. We have some very good quality players sitting on the bench and in there place we have players out of position and crap that just isn't up to it. Neville I will just never get it. Baines has been very good but has now been dropped for two successive games. osman is not a cm he is a winger at best. Faddy is our most inform stiker yet he changes it every week. stubbs is good cover but how do you expect jo and lescott to get a great partnership if they don't play together.

I think give faddy his place back alongside yak. also agree with the midfield of piernar cahill arteta and cars. I think the defence picks itself drop stubbs and get lescott back in the middle

With us lacking some players over the next few weeks wouldn't you like to see these guys given a few sub apperances. I would really like vidarsson given a chance in the middle especially with the current crop of crap we have

WHy oh Why won't he play baines he has looked the business when I have seen him and haven't seen him put a foot wrong. Lescott is a good left back but a better centre back. I would also argue that baines is a better left back than lescott

Blueboy my thoughts are that is a joke of a defence lescott and yobo need to learn to play together. Leaving baines out is a joke as he is very good and lescott is watsed at left back. stubbs is past it he should be cover not rolled out for such big games.