Have to ask this question lads. Do you think we are a better team with Carsley in it?
In my opinion 100% yes. I really noticed it on saturday when he went off injured, after he went off we looked nervous at the back. I know he isn't the greatest player in the world but we are a far stronger team with Cars sitting in front of the back 4. And i don't believe we have anyone to replace him when he missing, this includes Neville because i know people are going to suggest him.
On saturday Lee going off injured cost us 3 points. We didn't look to have problems at the back until then. Neville doesn't have the same positional sence as Carsley, he gives 100% but seems to chase after the ball alot and then gets caught out of position creating gaps infront of the center halfs. Any opinions