The jurys out on Atsu, a lot can happen between now & the end of the season. Personally I'd give Ossie another year as a squad player & wave goodbye to both the Milkman & the birdman. Think big Sil's being eased out & old father time is finally catching up with him. Alcaraz looks decent in spells but can't stay fit & would rather Browning, Pennington or Galloway got a chance. Ossie's a strange one as we all know his days as a starter have been gone pretty much since he was capped for England. Big character in the dressing room though, proper Evertonian, (we all regret some of our ideals as a kid!) & still has something to offer imo. (Hibbo's stand in performances of late have swayed my opinion on that.)