Hafnia

Samuel eto and Mario balotelli don't even belong in the same sentance. Eto has never been anything other than a goalscoring phenomenon who may have a strong opinion but just look at what he has achieved. Balotelli on the other hand is a loose cannon who has no regard for the team he plays for. Eto will be fine as long as things are fine, just in the way Southall was, just in the way Roy Keane was, like many other winners are.

Happy birthday Marco. Friday too, few beers no doubt.

Didn't get to see game, delighted with result though. Judging by comments Eto showed the type of forward play which Rom needs to develop in order to become the player many think he can be. I really hope Eto takes him aside and mentors him. Glad to see Howard prove doubters wrong.

Brilliant. I'm ok to watch then. Currently in centre parcs being fleeced for anything that they can charge you for. £5 a pint....

What channel are we on?

Cotto will be coming after you!!!,

Tough one this, Rom great finish but lazy all game. I thought McGeady was very good at times and the same for mirallas. Mirallas just...

One of those that. 9/10 in back of net, sat up and he leathered it.

Need to improve big time here. Not good enough. Defenders just look shaky.

Tremendous finish Brett, never questioned his finishing. He did control it but let's be honest it was on the deck if he miscontrolled that he should be sacked!!! Again though excellent finishing.

Told ya!!!!

Not at all. He can change games positively as he is a goalscorer. Is scoring goals going to change my opinion of him? No, because I've not questioned that part of his game. If he has a game where he controls the ball well, retains it and passes well then that's where you can call me out. That is the part of the game where he can help the team.

I'm gonna predict a big game for Rom, he needs it and could really kick us into gear. I want to see him play off the defenders shoulder.

Mate, a city fan season ticket holder (I even know a city fan) said whoever gets him is getting a class player. said city would be nothing without the likes of Milner and kolorov, they give the side an element of professionalism. Needs to play midfield to be really appreciated. Said the reason they beat bayern munich was down to Milner.

proper pro too. Its a strange one, but I watched him in a footballers golf tournament on sky, he impressed me with his will to win. Proper tried to get in the opponents head, no nicey nice "give you that 3 footer" - he made them hole them. Even though it was a charity event he just wanted to win. Old Jags was having a laugh (looked to have a good swing though)

remember thinking he was class at spurs after he joined from peterborough. Just never did it for us, I think you are right, injuries may have impacted him, he did have a good turn of pace.

nah, goals are goals. Rom has scored vital ones and his ability in front of the net isn't in question, i'm looking for his overall game and ability to be trusted to keep hold of the thing.

Not too sure about getting into the critical goals debate, every goal is critical, lets say Naismith scored a 3rd a gainst Arsenal at 2-0 up, it is highly like that Arsenal would never have had the "go" in them to get those two goals to get the draw. The final result may have been 3-0 and therefore Naismiths goal seen as the icing on the cake and nothing more. Basically at any stage of a game wherethe other team can get a couple, every goal is crucial. What I will say is that when in and around the 18 yard box, Naismith hits the target or tests the keeper more regularly than any of our players. If he had the chance that Barkley did against Arsenal in the FA Cup I would have fancied him to bury it, Ross went for the very top corner.

To be honest he probably should have been playing for them back in 2007. Seriously though its good to see. Some players forget what got them into the game in the first place and think they are too good to play at a certain level. He will appreciate his career far more as a result of this. Mate plays in a 7 a side team with John Barnes - he said the stuff he still does is jaw dropping. Davies will look like zidane at that level.

Yeah lets see Barkley playing just behind Eto and Lukaku with Mirallas out left and McGeady out right, with John Stones bringing the ball out of defence to give it to Besic who does a zidane spin, plays it to Barkley who runs past 4 players, passes it to Lukaku who holds off 3 players who are using him as a climbing frame and backheels it to Eto who rounds the keeper and puts it in with his head. Oooh yeah, lets drop players like Naismith, they don't do all that stuff. They just give you a minimum level of performance and effort that never seems to disappoint whilst the talented enigmatic players have an off day.

A work horse who can tackle, very good distribution - his range of passing is excellent, can cross a ball better than the majority of the players in the league. His problem is he can play a variety of positions and has therefore never been appreciated for the player he is. Can play in the middle, out wide, or right back. In the middle is his best position - he is captain material. A very, very good player. It shows what is wrong with the game when he can't get into Man City's side, he is more consistent than many of their players, just not spectacular enough for them.

Class player, get him. I would pay £10m for him never mind £5m.

Brett, get real. Barkley for all his talent does not have anywhere near the composure or decision making that Naismith has. I'm a huge Barkley fan but I'm sorry you are talking nonsense. Being a tremendously gifted footballer does not mean you do everything right all the time. Naismith has added an element of steel, graft, and finishing up front. All I read is drop him for Lukaku, drop him when Barkley is back. How's about they prove they can put in a performance like him first?

If you quote the post I was replying to then it would be far clearer.

better than schmichael, van der sar, or any modern era keeper my opinion.