SimonButtle

plenty of good possession, a bit poo in the final third though, we should going into the break ahead imo. Gerard for a home debut in the second half, COYB!!

Why didn't Jela leave that for Felli?

 

WBA remind me of Stoke under Pullis.

I know, and it's weird because they never used to play like that.

we really do need some more guille in the midfield imo, a sort of deep lying play maker type(maybe a fit Gibson would do tbh)

what a waste of a free kick

great run and shot from Barkley

Interested to see Osman's performance today, will he step it up from last week in front of the home fans.

shame it's only a loan, this would be a great addition to the midfield, as has been said im surprised they are letting him go.

I really hope Chelsea stick it up Moyes and United on Monday, and believe me im no Mourinho fan.

I think many are making judgement on what they've seen of him, regardless of anything else. I along with many others think he will be an excellent signing and exactly what we need.

No concern about him as a player, i think he will settle in straight away. Just the fee that concerns me £15m is an awful lot, imo should be no more than £10m

He was a stand out player in a shit team. :dont know:

I agree Bill, he will have huge pressure on him to deliver should we sign him.

Idiotic point. I used to loathe Donovan, but came around on him after seeing him at Everton. And if I were you, I'd think again about the connection between American nationalist sentiment and soccer fandom. In general, I'd say our clubs override our quest for American empire.

Not at all, it's my observation that after one good loan spell a certain section of the fanbase are desperate for us to get him back, he's mr average as far as im concerned and we have a few of them already, we don't need another. This is a forum and im entitled to my opinion so let's just agree to disagree, yes?

Gerard might get some game time tomorrow, get the crowd going, at home 1st game and all that, and it's only West Brom, if we could get a couple of goals first half, then it would be great to see him get 45mins

 

You got me wrong on 2 fronts

It was more a general point tbh

http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/martinez-hoping-add-blues-squad-5775444?

 

 

Please don't be Barry. Please don't be Barry. Please don't be Barry.

Good to see Roberto is still looking to be active in the market, but it must be slightly awkward, he needs a plan A for if Baines and Fellaini stay(i guess this is his one more in statement) and he needs a plan B for if they go, as we will need more than one signing then. The mancs need to make up their mind what they are doing, otherwise it will be a last day thing, and knowing us we won't replace in time.

 

Giving some young players a place on the bench and not using them doesn't improve them as much as working with a top professional like Donovan every day of the week would.

I reckon they will learn more from playing/training with someone like Deulofeu who is one of the worlds hottest young talents, and also a similar age to them and they can relate to him better than they would Donovan.

I do love how are US fans try to encourage a re-signing every window, but imo it's just another over 30 player, not needed.

What's with the 'fuck off'?

 

Not putting any player in any bracket just stating that my opinion would be he would be sold for around those figures.

 

Now go and learn some manners from your parents.

Sorry not meant in an offensive way, i apologise.

I watched some of the Athletico vs Barca game last night, and Athletico had a guy upfront called Diego Costa who i believe the shite were linked with the other week. Well talk about Suarez mk2, he was diving,rolling moaning to the ref, really don't understand why they would want another player like that.

He's not really though is he. Cabaye is only worth 12-15 million anyway.

Fuck off, you are putting him in the same bracket as McCarthy, Cabaye is a far better player imo, he was amazing that first season he was here

Min svenska är perfekt .

Yours would be

 

I'm sure that I make myself look like a complete idiot in several ways. Not sure spelling conference badly is one of them. Sorry if I misunderstood what you were saying, must be my lack of reading/spelling skills that threw me off.

 

Sincerely

Your Pal

You can have as many mistakes as you wish, English is not your first language.

Thats only if he is as good as people think he is, I'm holding fire on this one.

Personally i think there are better options in europe and abroad at £15m.

I have to say i do like the player but overall im leaning towards your viewpoint Bill, i agree, there must be other options for that kind of money.

What's funny is that..

 

a) Everton have made no indication whatsoever that they want McCarthy (officially)

b ) Wigan haven't put any price tag on him, let alone £15m (officially)

c) If anything was going to happen, or has happened you'd hear it first from Dave Whelan, way before SSN or the rags. (Not officially, but it is DW!)

 

 

Reading this forum you'd think McCarthy was the only midfielder in the world we could buy and considering its all sprouted from paper rumours I think this is getting a lot of wasted energy!

Pretty sure Whelan said at the start of the summer when there was us and spurs interested that he would cost nearer £20m

 

 

The value in McCarthy is that for the £15million you're buying someone to play at the heart of your midfield for the next 10 years.

Yeah, i guess there is that, he has worked with the manager, if Martinez stays for the time Moyes did then yes, we would see the best of McCarthy no doubt.

I think he will be ok as i don't think Martinez will start him every game. If we can get a CM/DM brought in and maybe shift Osman upfront, he can be gradually eased in over the season. He is going to need a settled 2 behind him though, whether it's Felli+Gibson, Gibson+Another, Felli+Another etc,etc. So that if he does lose the ball he doesn't have to have the worry about getting it back so much, just concentrate on what he's good at.