I do think Buddle is better than Denis, though I also like Denis. Buddle has proven himself on the MLS level several times. I'd compare the MLS to middle-tabled Championship teams (except I think LA would be at the top of the table), so he's at least been consistent.
That said, I really would rather have a younger player that we can develop, but already has a lot of experience. Vellios is good for the future, but I think DM is looking for a quick fix to our striking woes... I don't think we'll find one within our budget.