Vranny

I’ll be most curious to see what his role in the team is, especially when the players he’s looking to displace (Bernard, Richarlison and Sigurdsson) have all been big signings too. 

Most of the talk I ever hear about him is that he’s more of an attacking mid that’s been forced to play out wide for most of his career. He’s supposed to be pretty intelligent with his passing compared to most wide players for instance. He could make for a more mobile alternative to Gylfi that most of us have been crying out for. 

I’ve been a supporter since 06-07 for reference.

Turner

Jacobsen Senderos Williams Martina 

Van der meyde Gosling Castillo McGeady

Klaasen

Kone

4 hours ago, markjazzbassist said:

I keep saying it over and over, Zouma is the best CB they have.  Rudiger next and then Luiz and christensen.  Cahill is gone.  Any decent manager would keep zouma.  No way he comes here

I certainly wouldn’t rule out him coming here. Seems like he wants a transfer if he’s not seen as a starter at Chelsea and I don’t think there’s a whole heap separating him, Rudiger, Luiz and Christensen. 

On 29/06/2019 at 20:48, markjazzbassist said:

I’ve backed him since day 1 and said he will come good.  I still don’t think we will get Zouma and Mina will be the starter.

I still think we need another CB or Holgate to really step up. I think playing Keane and Mina together would be asking for trouble against pacey strikers when they both turn like ships. 

Tbh I do think Gana holds some blame for that goal. I don’t think there’s too much wrong with his anticipation, but I don’t think he reacts well to the situation once Martina falls over.

Rather than naively trying to win the ball from the side, I think he should be concentrating on just getting his body between Salah and the goal. I think he lets him slip past too easily by trying to tackle him from the side for sure. 

Also I don’t know how we’ve let another topic turn into a Gana debate 

The thing with Siggy is if you’re expecting him to be the main playmaker, always showing for the ball, then you’re going to be disappointed. That’s clearly Gomes’ role in the team. I see Gylfi more as an attacking third based player. He’s there to score goals, press up with DCL and provide the final ball (I honestly think he’d have more assists with a better striker and Walcott not getting so much game time).

While I do wish he’d present to the ball more when we’re struggling to break teams down, he’s certainly done more good than bad. I’d probably rate him as our best attacking player this season. 

The club needs to be competing regularly in Europe (Europa league qualifying or otherwise) if it wants to be a big player and break into the league’s current top 6 teams. Playing regularly in the Europa league is how we’re going to expand our squad, lure bigger names to our team and actually become a league contender again.

If you want us to finish 8th this year to avoid playing in Europe you may as well starting hoping for 8th place finishes every season. 

12 hours ago, Romey 1878 said:

He shouldn’t be that no matter what. We always leave it too late replacing players and fazing them out. It pisses me off. 

I can just see us dropping “developing Kenny for the future” as an excuse too. Worked out well for Garbutt like. 

I was glad to finally see Richarlison played on the right. Leaves Bernard/Lookman to play their naturally position on the left, forces Richo to look infield for teammates more often, rather than go it alone, and most importantly it keeps Theo off the teamsheet 

Gomes scored a great goal, Pickford made some great saves, and Kenny and Sigurdsson actually looked like they were trying, but I don’t think anyone deserves a vote (except maybe the cat). 

1 hour ago, pete0 said:

Unless Sigurdssen scores you struggle to notice him most games. Shocking he's been given a chance every week. 

Looking at the stats even when he scores he doesn't effect the result enough. Most of them are token. He's scored winners against Cardiff and most memorably Leicester but his other 7 haven't swayed the result. Of his three assist only one changed a defeat to a draw. If he was doing more for the team over the 90 I'd not highlight the lack of impact his goals make but considering he's invisible for most games and the justification is he pops up with a belter, it's damning that he offers even less than I thought. What's the point in playing him for a consolations goal. 

It's time to give someone a chance to help the team. 

I don’t know if it’s a tactical decision or a failing of Sigurdsson himself, but he absolutely has to get himself more involved in games. At least when he gets played as one of the holding mids he actually presents for the ball regularly, but then his defending in that position isn’t up to standard (although the same goes for Gomes unfortunately). 

Could be time to drop one of Sigurdsson or Gomes and play Bernard behind the striker. I don’t really know what else to do with the team tbh. 

12 hours ago, markjazzbassist said:

3 players is nothing, brands loaned out close to 12 players this summer, that is amazing.  Walsh did some good, PickfordGylfi Keane Gana Lookman DCL the highlights for me.  But he bought too mnay expensive clankers Bolasie Tosun Walcott Schniederlin Williams Martina Klaassen Rooney Sandro.  that's about a 55% success rate and Lookman and DCl haven't come good yet so it's even lower if you're counting actual play now talent.

Brands got Gomes Richarlison Mina Digne Bernard.  The only clanker so far is Mina and the jury is still out, Gomes is a loan so even if he doesn't light it up i can't count that against him.  and he has started most matches.

Trust me, it was more than just 3 players he got rid of  The cynic in me just expects us to be bringing in a new DoF another few years down the road, at which time we’ll be celebrating him clearing out Brands deadwood  I’d rather wait several more months before branding Brands a saviour myself (the same goes for writing off Silva too). 

1 hour ago, Romey 1878 said:

 

 

The guy needs a bit of love atm 

3 hours ago, markjazzbassist said:

Steve Walsh fucked this club over so hard, Brands is doing the Lord's work, he truly is. 

Weren't we all praising Walsh when we managed to dump the likes of Gibson, Pienaar and Oviedo on Sunderland? I'm not saying I was a fan of Walsh, but I'll be interested to see if the tide starts to turn on Brands if we don't sign anyone over January.

I’m hoping Marco gives DCL a solid run of games upfront after the festive period and sees how Richarlison goes on the right. I’ve been a consistent defender of Walcott, but I think it’s time to give something else a try. Walcott seems tailor made to make an impact off the bench anyway with his pace. 

In the long run I think we should be looking  for a left footer to play that inverted winger role on the right though. 

1 hour ago, Bailey said:

Playing Bernard as a box to box is something I never thought I would hear based on one game where we were ahead early and could play on the counter all game and in more space than we would normally get.

It sounds like a kid trying to fit all of his favourite players into a team on fifa 

12 hours ago, AlbanyNYToffee said:

We will likely go back to 4 at the back- think Marco wanted to match Burnley's 2 strikers with 3 CB's. Brighton completely different set up.

 

I think you’re right, but on the flip side Bernard seemed to suit the inside forward role he played with Digne playing LWB, so it might be worth persevering with. 

I’d be going with a mobile frontline to press their defence, so either DCL or Richo up front. I’d be tempted to go with DCL to help us retain the ball a bit more, while still providing a counter attack and pressing option. 

I’ve also been a bit worried about Mina, so wouldn’t mind seeing the Zouma-Keane partnership re-established. 

10 hours ago, Cornish Steve said:

To answer your question about who he should replace in the current lineup, then Walcott. 

You could possibly play Siggy up front and push Richo out wide, but I think you’re stretching there mate 

I’m actually excited to play them, possibly for the first time ever. We’re in a good run of form, I’m feeling a lot of confidence in our team and I think it’ll be a good opportunity to see where our squad is at. 

5 hours ago, hafnia said:

Interesting stat..... 20 goals out of circa 320 prem goals scored this season have come from counter attack/fast breaks. That's about 1 in 16.....

We have 2, Leicester lead on 4 and Bournemouth and Liverpool have 3. 

No place for him to play his trade here me thinks. 

Leicester was actually the team I thought he might go to next if he stays in the prem haha. 

2 hours ago, Btay said:

@Romey 1878 it’s happening...

Watch him sign for Liverpool now 

16 hours ago, hafnia said:

I'd have siggy all day long ahead of Barkley but Barkley was a far better and important player than people gave him credit for. 

Don’t disagree with that either. I still think he was a very lazy player for us though. If he wasn’t in form in attack, then he certainly wasn’t going to make up for it by helping out with defensive work, like Siggy is capable of. 

On 05/11/2018 at 02:52, SpartyBlue said:

I'm a little surprised there isn'ttt more mention of Digne's performance. He was a problem for them all day. Of course hes been so good consistently that maybe we are just coming to expect it.

Digne would’ve been my MOTM at half time. Caused Brighton a lot of trouble with his runs and crosses. In the end I couldn’t go past two great goals from Ritchie, but he was right up there too.