Man of the Match v Manchester United

[MikeO]

Current Player of the Season totals...

James McCarthy...173

Ross Barkley...159

Kevin Mirallas...125

Gareth Barry...127

Tim Howard...122

Seamus Coleman...117

Steven Naismith...103

Gerard Deulofeu...91

Romelu Lukaku...81

Leighton Baines...79

John Stones...62

Steven Pienaar...56

Bryan Oviedo...54

Sylvain Distin...48

Leon Osman...23

Antolin Alcaraz...14

Phil Jagielka...13

Marouane Fellaini...10

Aiden McGeady...10

Nikica Jelavic...3

Johnny Heitinga...2

Tony Hibbert...1

Arouna Kone...1

Joel Robles...1

Previous MOTM winners...

Crystal Palace (H)...John Stones

Sunderland (A)...John Stones

Arsenal (H)...Steven Naismith

Fulham (A)...Steven Naismith

Newcastle (A)...Gerard Deulofeu

Swansea (H)...Tim Howard

Cardiff (H)...James McCarthy

Arsenal (A)...Ross Barkley

West Ham (H)...James McCarthy

Chelsea (A)...James McCarthy

Swansea (H)...Steven Naismith

Tottenham (A)...Steven Naismith

West Ham (H)...Kevin Mirallas

Liverpool (A)...Kevin Mirallas

Stevenage (A)...Kevin Mirallas

West Brom (A)...Kevin Mirallas

Norwich (H)...Gareth Barry

Queens Park Rangers (H)...Bryan Oviedo

Stoke (A)...Leighton Baines

Southampton (H)...James McCarthy

Sunderland (H)...Bryan Oviedo

Swansea (A)...Seamus Coleman

Fulham (H)...Steven Pienaar

Arsenal (A)...Tim Howard

Man United (A)...Tim Howard & Bryan Oviedo tie

Stoke City (H)...Gerard Deulofeu

Liverpool (H)...Ross Barkley

Palace (A)...Tim Howard

Tottenham (H)...James McCarthy

Aston Villa (A)...Tim Howard

Hull City (H)...James McCarthy

Manchester City (A)...James McCarthy

Newcastle (H)...Romelu Lukaku

Fulham (A)...Sylvain Distin

West Ham (A)...Leighton Baines

Chelsea (H)...Gareth Barry

Cardiff (A)...Ross Barkley

Stevenage (H)...Ross Barkley

West Brom (H)...Seamus Coleman

Norwich (A)...Ross Barkley

[Ian C]

Gave it to Coleman, exceptional.

 

Baines and Barry were terrific too. Naismith would have it if he put away one or two of his chances.

[Steve_E]

Between Coleman and Mirallas. Voted for Coleman. He's a physical freak.

[Hafnia]

Coleman... Beast.

[msloan78]

I don't understand how Coleman can keep going at that pace for the full 90 minutes. Reminiscent of Cafu!

 

Great performance by all today!

[Peter H]

Coleman!

[Romey 1878]

Mirallas.

 

Could've gone with Coleman but Mirallas added a goal to his performance as well.

[MikeO]

Seamus.

[efc1111]

Gave it to Mirallas for a much improved performance and great goal, but there were a few outstanding performances today, not least Coleman and Barry, and Howard made some important stops too. I was pleased with the way Alcaraz came on and slotted in seamlessly - and showed how to meet a corner too!

[MC11]

Mirallas, Coleman was boss though

[Cornish Steve]

Coleman.

 

It was also great to see Alcaraz fit like a glove when he came on. He's the perfect squad player.

[Guest]

I thought Mccarthy was head and shoulders above everybody. The lad is a freak! breaking play up with his long stride time and time again.But when he gets the ball its just as good he wastes nothing. I was staggered by his work rate today. £12 million? he is worth double that easy. Coleman was excellent don't get me wrong but McCarthy is my new man crush .

[johnh]

I agree about McCarthy but for me Barry shaded it. The Everton midfield were awesome and got even better when Barkley went off.

In Coleman and Baines we have the best attacking full backs in the Premiership. John Stones is going to be the real deal. Another year in the gym and another stone in weight, he will play for England for 10 or 12 years.

[Shukes]

I'm going for McCarthy too

Had it all today, effort, intelligence, bite and even put in a few kicks to let to know they can't hold on to the ball.

How many interceptions and clearances did he make?

[MC11]

Coleman.

 

It was also great to see Alcaraz fit like a glove when he came on. He's the perfect squad player.

Yes I agree he's a very very good player. If those injury problems wernt there he'd be a fantastic player.

 

His last ditch challenge on Rooney was fantastic.

[Gwlad]

Difficult choice, they all give their all but gave it to Coleman. Also pleased at how Alcaraz fitted in.

[duncanmckenzieismagic]

Still can't work out how to vote on my phone but couldn't decide between Mirallas and Coleman anyway

[Mogsy]

McCarthy for me. Never let anyone through and showed how much we missed him last Wednesday! Player of the season I'd say.

[Hafnia]

Got to say alcaraz is a wise old Fox, beast of a leap on him too.

[c1982]

Mirallas... obviously Coleman was great too. Special mention for Stones who was much better defensively after midweek.

 

McCarthy gets my final mention as basically he could get my vote every game. Joe Parkinson is my favourite ever Everton player (just ahead of Big Dunc)... McCarthy is so similar and then some to Parkinson - love him!

[verreauxi]

Coleman.

[coxy051]

Coleman. With McCarthy close second!

[markjazzbassist]

McCarthy. Coleman and Mirallas a close second

[marcopaulo]

i'd have gone for mccarthy but he was lucky not to give away a pen just after we scored..could've made the game very different

 

coleman instead..was awesome

[NyarkosLeftToe]

McCarthy for me, the lads unreal, if it weren't for Baines he would be my favourite player, but I love Baines too much!

 

Coleman was class and glad to see Mirallas back to his best, he's poor for weeks now

[Sibdane]

Coleman -- Just never stops running that wing.

[Matt]

Barry

[Cake]

David Moyes - for being a fine example of a resentment, caught in the headlights.

[Guest]

You have to wonder don't you? Coleman bombing down the right and Moyes did nothing to change it? no Janazui or how you spell it to go forward and peg him back? he seems like he is a rookie manager at times. Loads of forwards doing nothing, it seems like he didn't want to play Felli as he would have got slagged for it .